Question

Despite some similarities, the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire and the Ludlow Massacre played out very differently for the workers involved. What factors were responsible for the different gains made by labor in these two events? Had labor relations evolved in the twenty years between the two events? How? What factor did geography play in the two strikes, between the dense industrial East and the open mines of the West?

Answer 1

PLEASE LIKE THIS ANSWER, IT HELPS ME A LOT. THANK YOU!!!

EXPLANATION:

At the turn of the twentieth century, conflicts between labor and management shook the expanding industrial sector, sometimes culminating in violence. The Triangle Shirtwaist Company was the site of a fire in which 146 people died due to many safety features which were neglected. Similalrly, in April 1914 in Colorado, violence erupted once again in what became known as the Ludlow Massacre which was the massacre of miners on strike, as well as their families which resulted in the deaths of over 50, 11 in which were found to be children.

Despite some similarities, the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire and the Ludlow Massacre played out very differently for the workers involved. The factors that were responsible for the different gains made by labor in these two events included the attention to the fangers of these condtions including neglected safety features, several locked exits which led to a series of changes in law and regulation that better protected the employees. In addition to the Trainee Shirtwaist factory fire, the Ludlow Massacre was an attack on striking coal miners and their families which resulted in the death of 25 people, in which 11 were children.

The employees had been striking to protest the low pay and dangerous working conditions they were subjected to while working in the mines which essentially let to public outcry over the death of so many women and chilren. With labor relations evolving in the 20 years between the two events in social and politcal ways. As the Triangle Shirtwaist factor fire had happened, little change including better regulations on labor was enticed.

However, after the miners strike, they were able to accomplish better unions, which allowed them more benefits, more insurances, and overall a better outcome despite the death toll. In addition to the differences within the social and politcal changes that occured, the geography played a big role because of the different industries.

For example, with the circumstances revolving the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire, this was taking place in the East with factories, and a more city like feel while in the west it was more underdevloped, and had different sources of resources which ran their economies, and their markets. Overall, it is clear to see some similarities between the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire and the Ludlow Massacre although both played out very differently for the workers involved.

Although both involving some kind of death toll, it showed the way the minds of the goverment was at when it happened. Did these deaths mean something and cause something to change, or were they just another thing looked over? I believe that although very different circumstances, the Ludlow Massacre sparked more change for the laborers, and gave them more as a result of their strikings.

PLEASE LIKE THIS ANSWER, IT HELPS ME A LOT. THANK YOU!!!