Question

A woman received a score of 3.7 (out of 5.0) from her supervisor on her first...

A woman received a score of 3.7 (out of 5.0) from her supervisor on her first performance appraisal. She began to experience severe sexual harassment from a co-worker who was a top performer and well-liked by everyone in the department. She complained about the harassment to her supervisor and to the human resources department on numerous occasions, but the employer never addressed the complaints. On a subsequent performance appraisal the woman received a score of 3.04. The woman was laid off shortly thereafter, with the employer citing the fact that she had the lowest overall performance rating as the basis for the decision. The woman sues. What should the court decide and why?

Your answer must include:

Any relevant legal principles and practical advice on performance appraisals from the reading, cases and lectures;

Any mistakes the employer made in handling the performance appraisal process or any other employment issue;

Any legal claims the employee could raise;

For each legal claim the employee raises:

state the legal rule/prima facie case the employee must establish to prevail AND

identify the facts that support the employee’s legal claims and arguments

Any arguments or legal defenses the employer could raise;

For each argument or legal defense the employer raises:

state the legal elements the employer must establish to prevail AND

identify the facts that support the employer’s arguments  

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Civil Rights Act Title VII played a critical role in the workplace harassment or discrimination case. This title prohibits discrimination from employer on any kind of bias like sex, religion, race, sect, etc. This serves the basis of providing equal employment opportunities to all.

Workplace retaliation is the adverse action taken by an employer, against an employee who had recently complained about workplace harassment or discrimination. In this kind of situation, government has asked the employers to consider the complaint very seriously and take measures to address it. If the employer in turn, takes any action against the employee, the government has given the rights to employee to speak up and file against the retaliation.

This is a clear case of sexual harassment at workplace as well as workplace retaliation. Even though the supervisor as well as the HR Department were informed about the sexual harassment of plaintiff, the employer did not take any step to address the same and instead fired her citing performance issues. So both the co-worker as well as the management are equally guilty in this case.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Mary Barnes was employed by the Manwell Company of Maine, Wyoming [324 full-time employees].   She worked...
Mary Barnes was employed by the Manwell Company of Maine, Wyoming [324 full-time employees].   She worked at an off-site location near Maine keeping track of the inventory in that facility. Mary was the only female in the building and Milton, her supervisor, subjected her to occasional verbal abuse. [Milton had never received training concerning sexual harassment in his eight years with the company.] He often used vulgar language to refer to women, regularly told lewd jokes and made gestures insulting...
What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from reading their paper? How does...
What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from reading their paper? How does the topic relate to you and your current or past job? Critique the paper in terms of the organization and quality. Team 3 answer questions above. Part I In today’s world we see fear among people when dealing with sexual harassment. This leads to people not reporting sexual harassment. A misconception about sexual harassment is that it’s only about touching and forcing other people...
Case Study: Henderson Printing is a small- to medium-sized manufacturer of account books, ledgers, and various...
Case Study: Henderson Printing is a small- to medium-sized manufacturer of account books, ledgers, and various types of record books used in business. Located in Halifax, the company has annual sales of about $12 million, mostly in the Atlantic provinces. The owner, George Henderson, is a firm believer in making a high-quality product that will stand up to many years of use. He uses only high-grade paper, cover stock, and binding materials. Of course, this has led to high production...
Frank Frausto delivered newspapers for Phoenix Newspapers, Inc., under a renewable 6- month contract called a...
Frank Frausto delivered newspapers for Phoenix Newspapers, Inc., under a renewable 6- month contract called a “Delivery Agent Agreement.” The agreement identified Fausto as an independent contractor. Phoenix collected payments from customers and responded to customer complaints regarding delivery. Frausto was assigned the route for his deliveries and was required to deliver the papers within a certain time period each day. Frausto used his own vehicle to deliver the papers and had to provide proof of insurance to Phoenix. Phoenix...
Janet Broom and Darla Miller were employed as certified medication aide and cook, respectively, at the...
Janet Broom and Darla Miller were employed as certified medication aide and cook, respectively, at the employer's residential care facility located in Norman, Oklahoma. Both employees suspected another employee of stealing and using drugs, intended for use by residents of the faculty, from the facility’s medication room. Broom and Miller decided to report the suspected employee based on their observation that she had falsified medical drug log books to conceal her theft from facility managers. The facility’s Employee Handbook clearly...
3 SECURING THE WORKFORCE Diversity management in X-tech, a Japanese organisation This case is intended to...
3 SECURING THE WORKFORCE Diversity management in X-tech, a Japanese organisation This case is intended to be used as a basis for class discussion rather than as an illustration of the effective or ineffective handling of an administrative situation. The name of the company is disguised. INTRODUCTION In light of demographic concerns, in 2012, the Japanese government initiated an effort to change the work environment in order to secure the workforce of the future. Japan is world renowned for its...
2. SECURING THE WORKFORCE Diversity management in X-tech, a Japanese organisation This case is intended to...
2. SECURING THE WORKFORCE Diversity management in X-tech, a Japanese organisation This case is intended to be used as a basis for class discussion rather than as an illustration of the effective or ineffective handling of an administrative situation. The name of the company is disguised. INTRODUCTION In light of demographic concerns, in 2012, the Japanese government initiated an effort to change the work environment in order to secure the workforce of the future. Japan is world renowned for its...