Question

Discuss the similarities between Carl Jung and Carl Rogeres. How do their theories explain the self?

Discuss the similarities between Carl Jung and Carl Rogeres. How do their theories explain the self?

Homework Answers

Answer #1
  • Both Rogers and Jung emphasize the importance of the human individual, but with Rogers the emphasis is on the "individual" (autonomy, internal locus of evaluation, experience, growth, maturity, etc.) whereas with Jung the emphasis is on the "human" (human instincts, common archetypal structures, types of personality, shared responses to situations, human patterns of development, etc.)
  • The idea of a shared humanity runs all through Rogers's work, and Jung emphasizes the intrinsic value of the individual.
  • Similarity between their means of psychotherapy is that both recognize the individuality of the patient and his or her problems and the need for a strong relationship between doctor/therapist and patient/client.
  • The therapist has to be present, accessible and open at any moment to whatever unique feeling or issues the client shares and the therapist should experience all the feelings that his or her client is communicating during the session.Like Rogers, Jung also acknowledged the truth of all of this. He insists upon devotion to the patient, and upon seeing him or her as an individual and unique person.
  • Rogers speaks of incongruence between self and experience;a discrepancy frequently develops between the self as perceived, and the actual experience of the organism. In the course of therapy a client often learns how much of his behavior, even how much of the feeling he experiences, is not real, is not something which flows from the genuine reactions of his organism, but is a facade, a front, behind which he has been hiding. He discovers how much of his life is guided by what he thinks he should be, not by what he is.
  • This facade is close to what Jung calls the persona (both of them have used the term "mask" in explaining the concept) The persona is the individual's system of adaptation to, or the manner he assumes in dealing with the world.
  • Rogers says of the "actualizing tendency", it is the inherent tendency of the organism to develop all its capacities in ways which serve to maintain or enhance the organism.It involves development toward the differentiation of organs and of functions, expansion in terms of growth, expansion of effectiveness. It is development toward autonomy and away from heteronomy, or control by external forces.
  • Jung uses similiar term of individuation,the process by which a person becomes a psychological "individual," that is, a separate, indivisible unity or "whole" which is similar to self actualization.
Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
what are the similarities and differences between the monetarist and new classical theories?
what are the similarities and differences between the monetarist and new classical theories?
Discuss the major similarities and differences between U.S. GAAP and IFRS. Which of the differences do...
Discuss the major similarities and differences between U.S. GAAP and IFRS. Which of the differences do you find most interesting? If there is a convergence between U.S. GAAP and IFRS, would you choose the U.S. GAAP or IFRS method? Why?
Discuss the interaction between leader self-sacrifice and self-confidence as researched by Cremer and van Knippenberg. How...
Discuss the interaction between leader self-sacrifice and self-confidence as researched by Cremer and van Knippenberg. How does this relate to leadership effectiveness? How is this effect mediated by collective identification?
Explain the main similarities and differences between learning how to drive and learning how to write...
Explain the main similarities and differences between learning how to drive and learning how to write an essay?
Discuss the similarities and differences between wave and tidal energy
Discuss the similarities and differences between wave and tidal energy
- Describe the major principles in classical and operant conditioning. What are the similarities and differences...
- Describe the major principles in classical and operant conditioning. What are the similarities and differences between the two? - Describe the three systems of memory and explain how they are connected to the notion of learning. - Explain three of the five theories of forgetting. Which of these three theories do you find the most compelling? Why? - Explain the connection between “thinking” and language. 5. Describe Noam Chomsky’s theory of language acquisition. Do you agree? Why or why...
1. Explain the similarities and dis-similarities between private auto and taxi. Name the major stakeholders in...
1. Explain the similarities and dis-similarities between private auto and taxi. Name the major stakeholders in urban public transportation. Discuss their significance and the major role each plays. Define and explain the importance of Environmental Impact Assessment (Statement) in urban infrastructure projects. What is the principal objective in carrying out transportation project evaluation? Name five (5) of the costs that a motorist (road user) would normally incur in owing a vehicle. Explain the operational modalities of "reverse commuting" auto-oriented cities....
Discuss similarities and difference between prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes (20 marks)
Discuss similarities and difference between prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes
Discuss the similarities and differences between the discounted dividend and corporate valuation models.
Discuss the similarities and differences between the discounted dividend and corporate valuation models.
(3) psychological theories that attempt to explain emotion. Discuss each, paying particular attention to how they...
(3) psychological theories that attempt to explain emotion. Discuss each, paying particular attention to how they view the order of the occurrence of the three factors involved in emotion (physiological activation, expressive behavior, & conscious experience).