Question

Facts: For many years, New York City has had to deal with vandalism and defacement of...

Facts:

For many years, New York City has had to deal with vandalism and defacement of public property caused by unauthorized graffiti. In an effort to stop the damage, the city banned the sale of aerosol spray-paint cans and broad-tipped indelible markers to persons under age twenty-one years of age. The new rule also prohibited people from possessing these items on property other than their own. Within a year, five people under age twenty-one were cited for violations of these regulations and 871 individuals were arrested for actually making graffiti.

Lindsey Vincenty and other artists wished to create graffiti on legal surfaces, such as canvas, wood and clothing. Unable to buy supplies in the city or to carry them into the city from elsewhere, Vincenty and others filed a lawsuit on behalf of themselves and other young artists against Michael Bloomberg, the city's mayor and others. The plaintiffs claimed that, among other things, the new rules violated their right to free speech.

Questions:

  1. How can the plaintiffs argue that the city's new rules violate their freedom of speech? Explain using legal principles from chapter four.
  2. How can the city's mayor and others argue that the new rules do not result in a free speech violation? Explain using legal principles from chapter four.
  3. Will the city's ban be subject to strict scrutiny, intermediate scrutiny or the rational basis test? Explain.
  4. Based on your answer to question four, does the city's ban result in an equal protection violation because it only applies to persons under age twenty-one? Why or why not? Explain and apply the proper standard of review.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

1. The plaintiffs can argue that the city's new rule violates their freedom of speech as the ban is content-neutral and it burdens more speech than it was necessary to city to achieve its goals to protect the city from vandalism.

2. City's mayor can argue that the ban is on certain types fo goods and if the rule is narrowly tailored to make it content specific then the city would not be able to achieve its goals of bringing this ordinance.

3. It will be subject to strict scrutiny as the government will have to prove that the interest is compelling enough and necessitates the ban as there are no other means available at the disposal of the government.

4. It does violate the equal protection violation because it only applies to a person under the age of 21, however, such actions can be committed by a person who is over the age of 21 and it does not serve the full purpose of imposing such ban on only to the age restriction of 21 years.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Pfizer was established in 1849 in Brooklyn, New York by cousins Charles Pfizer and Charles Erhart...
Pfizer was established in 1849 in Brooklyn, New York by cousins Charles Pfizer and Charles Erhart with a loan of $2,500 from Pfizer’s father.2 Today, 167 years later, Pfizer Inc. has international revenues of $49 billion, which makes it the second-largest pharmaceutical manufacturer in the world.3 Despite Pfizer’s success, the company has faced many challenges over the last few decades. The pharmaceutical industry is heavily influenced by legal, political, and technological forces, and all indications are that the industry will...
What role could the governance of ethics have played if it had been in existence in...
What role could the governance of ethics have played if it had been in existence in the organization? Assess the leadership of Enron from an ethical perspective. THE FALL OF ENRON: A STAKEHOLDER FAILURE Once upon a time, there was a gleaming headquarters office tower in Houston, with a giant tilted "£"' in front, slowly revolving in the Texas sun. The Enron Corporation, which once ranked among the top Fortune 500 companies, collapsed in 2001 under a mountain of debt...
Why do you suppose the marketing of the tax shelters at KPMG grew so fast? a.Transformational...
Why do you suppose the marketing of the tax shelters at KPMG grew so fast? a.Transformational leadership b. Moral manager c. Social learning theory d. Moral intensity [The following information applies to the question.] In Chapter 4 we discussed the artificial tax shelter arrangements developed by KPMG LLP for wealthy clients that led to the settlement of a legal action with the Department of Treasury and the Internal Revenue Service. On August 29, 2005, KPMG admitted to criminal wrongdoing and...
Mattel Responds to Ethical Challenges Business Ethics This case was written by Debbie Thorne, John Fraedrich,...
Mattel Responds to Ethical Challenges Business Ethics This case was written by Debbie Thorne, John Fraedrich, O. C. Ferrell, and Jennifer Jackson, with the editorial assistance of Jennifer Sawayda. This case was developed for classroom discussion rather than to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of an administrative, ethical, or legal discussion by management. All sources used for this case were obtained through publicly available material. Mattel, Inc. is a world leader in the design, manufacture, and marketing of family...
1. What are the requirements for successful price discrimination? Does this type of dry cleaning qualify?...
1. What are the requirements for successful price discrimination? Does this type of dry cleaning qualify? 2. What are other examples of price discrimination? 3. The effectiveness of price discrimination is a different question than whether businesses should be able to discriminate by price. Is this an issue that deserves regulation, or is it best left to the market? Why Women Pay More From dry cleaning to haircuts, women often pay more than men due to gender pricing. Find out...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics Enron finds itself in this case. How would you describe the ethical culture and levels of trust at Enron? Provide reasons for your assessment. THE FALL OF ENRON: A STAKEHOLDER FAILURE Once upon a time, there was a gleaming headquarters office tower in Houston, with a giant tilted "£"' in front, slowly revolving in the Texas sun. The Enron Corporation, which once ranked among...
Discuss how the respective organizations’ relations with stakeholders could have potentially been affected by the events...
Discuss how the respective organizations’ relations with stakeholders could have potentially been affected by the events that took place at Enron and how the situation could have been dealt with differently to prevent further damage? THE FALL OF ENRON: A STAKEHOLDER FAILURE Once upon a time, there was a gleaming headquarters office tower in Houston, with a giant tilted "£"' in front, slowly revolving in the Texas sun. The Enron Corporation, which once ranked among the top Fortune 500 companies,...
Please read the article and answear about questions. Determining the Value of the Business After you...
Please read the article and answear about questions. Determining the Value of the Business After you have completed a thorough and exacting investigation, you need to analyze all the infor- mation you have gathered. This is the time to consult with your business, financial, and legal advis- ers to arrive at an estimate of the value of the business. Outside advisers are impartial and are more likely to see the bad things about the business than are you. You should...
Delta airlines case study Global strategy. Describe the current global strategy and provide evidence about how...
Delta airlines case study Global strategy. Describe the current global strategy and provide evidence about how the firms resources incompetencies support the given pressures regarding costs and local responsiveness. Describe entry modes have they usually used, and whether they are appropriate for the given strategy. Any key issues in their global strategy? casestudy: Atlanta, June 17, 2014. Sea of Delta employees and their families swarmed between food trucks, amusement park booths, and entertainment venues that were scattered throughout what would...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT