Question

Describe why Kant would not agree with physicians lying to their patients regarding a diagnosis. Provide...

Describe why Kant would not agree with physicians lying to their patients regarding a diagnosis. Provide an example to support your case.

Science   Nursing   
0 0
Add a commentTranscribed image text
Next >

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Kant would not agree with physicians lying to their patients regarding a diagnosis as his philosophical ground for our claims of right and wrongs may be the deontological view according to which certain categorical imperatives should not be surpassed in our actions. Both the ways and the ends should be justified. Thus morally telling a lie is wrong and no matter what the justification be we should not lie. For example, if a patient is suffering from cancer and we lie to him regarding his disease because we fear that he will get depressed a lot. This may be right according to the utilitarian concept however according to the Kantian view this is wrong. In fact, the patient may not get a choice for making the end of life decisions of making a will for his legal heirs.

0 0
Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Log In

Sign Up

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Describe the manners in which patients and physicians communicate and respond to one another. Describe the...
Describe the manners in which patients and physicians communicate and respond to one another. Describe the many socially constructed factors that shape or even dictate many of these interactions. For example, do physicians and patients have different understandings of illness? How does authority shape these interactions?
After months of trying, Jani’s parents and physicians narrow their search for a diagnosis down to...
After months of trying, Jani’s parents and physicians narrow their search for a diagnosis down to two contenders – bipolar disorder with psychotic features and schizophrenia. Use the memoir and the DSM to make a case for diagnosing one disorder over the other. What details about Jani’s behavior support your choice? What symptoms do the disorders share? How are they different? What factors contribute to the difficulty of making a definitive diagnosis? Information from the book January First: A Child's...
Describe your relationship with patient. How would you describe the patients overall medical and emotional condition?...
Describe your relationship with patient. How would you describe the patients overall medical and emotional condition? Why did the patient choose your clinic?
Indicate whether you agree or disagree with the statement and provide a short rationale to support...
Indicate whether you agree or disagree with the statement and provide a short rationale to support your decision. As a firm increases the percentage of debt financing used, the component cost of equity capital increases. Agree or disagree, and why.
How influential are physicians’ decisions regarding end of life care and their associated costs? Is the...
How influential are physicians’ decisions regarding end of life care and their associated costs? Is the decision to sign into hospice based upon medical advice, social issues, or some other factor? Why are U.S. urban Black nursing home residents less likely to avail themselves of hospice services? Physicians’ decisions regarding end of life care and the associated costs are very influential. Although patients and their families make the ultimate decisions of what to do, the physicians guide the patient and...
Explain why on a overview of all patients, patients heights would be categorical but when looking...
Explain why on a overview of all patients, patients heights would be categorical but when looking at each individual patient their heights are continuous. Example: There are twelve patients that are over 6ft tall with patient 123 with the tallest height of 6 ft 2 inches.
Provide reasons why you would or would not implement a decision support system (DSS) within an...
Provide reasons why you would or would not implement a decision support system (DSS) within an organization. Provide specific examples to justify your positions.
Describe Chip-Off. In what situations would this be a valuable procedure? Why do you think that?...
Describe Chip-Off. In what situations would this be a valuable procedure? Why do you think that? Find (2) scholarly articles from the Maryville Library or a reputable journal discussing Chip Off. Write 2-3 paragraphs for each article summarizing it. Do you agree with their rationale in the articles regarding chip-off? Would it be a valuable procedure? Why or why not?
Do you agree with the policy maker’s cost-containment strategies. Describe why you agree or disagree and...
Do you agree with the policy maker’s cost-containment strategies. Describe why you agree or disagree and include one or more insights from your readings that relate to the the question of how information technology could, or could not, help contain costs while supporting health care reform initiatives.
For each case history provide: a diagnosis; list the criteria required for the diagnosis; and provide...
For each case history provide: a diagnosis; list the criteria required for the diagnosis; and provide examples from the case history for each of the criteria listed. For example, if one of the criteria for a diagnosis is "delusions", then you should list "delusions, e.g., believes he is receiving special/hidden messages from television programs that he only understands". Shorty Rheinbold (Morrison, 1995, p.252-253) Seated in the clinician's waiting room, Shorty Rheinbold should have been relaxed. The lighting was soft and...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT