Question

Decision Scenario #7 Helen and John Kent waited nervously in the small consulting room while Laurie...

Decision Scenario #7 Helen and John Kent waited nervously in the small consulting room while Laurie Stent, their genetic counselor, went to tell Dr. Carles Blatz that they had arrived to talk to him. ?I regret that I have some bad new for you,? Dr. Blatz told them. ?the karyotyping that we do after aminocentesis shows a chromosomal abnormality.? He looked at them, and Helen felt she could hardly breathe. ?What is it?? she asked. ?It?s a condition known as tisomy-21, and it produces a birth defect we call Down syndrome. You may have heard of it under the old name of mongolism.? ?Oh, God,? John said. ?How bad is it?? ?Such children are always mentally retarded,? Dr. Blatz said. ?Some are severely retarded and others just twenty or so points below the average. Thy have some minor physical deformities, and they sometimes have heart damage. They typically don?t live beyond their thirties, but by and large they seem happy and have good dispositions.? Helen and John Looked at each other with great sadness. ?What do you think we should do?? Helen asked. ?Should I have an abortion, and then we could try again?? ?I don?t know,? John said. ?I really don?t know.? You?ve had a hard time being pregnant these last five months, and you?d have to go through that again. Besides, there?s no guarantee this wouldn?t happen again.? ?But this won?t be the normal baby we wanted,? Helen said. ?Maybe in the long run we?ll be even happier than we are now.? Helen and John Kent are married and looking forward to having a child. Helen is pregnant. The doctors inform them that the fetus has Trisomy-21 which is produces Down syndrome. It is impossible to determine the degree of impairment or differences in utero. They are considering whether or not to go through with the pregnancy. Should she have an abortion and try again to have a child? How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles of: (Respond using the principles of a rule utilitarian?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

She should have an abortion and try again to have a child using in vitro options. As per the ethical principles of rule-utilitarianism, the moral rightness of an action depends on the rightness of the rules that lets it achieve the goodness of greatest value. The best rule of conduct in this case is abortion to avoid the consequence of having a child with trisomy-21, which causes Down’s syndrome. Any rule which gives maximum benefit or positive outcomes becomes the best rule, which in this case is to abort the pregnancy. This would make them free of any future worries about a child with Down’s syndrome and will free them from the burden of taking care of such a child.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Scenario 7 ?My husband and I have talked over the matter in great detail,? Marge Gower...
Scenario 7 ?My husband and I have talked over the matter in great detail,? Marge Gower said. ?We don?t care about the sex of the child, but we know exactly the kinds of features we want.? ?Mrs. Gower,? Dr. Louise Singh said, ?you?ve got to understand that we?re not running a mail-order-catalog business for babies.? ?I?m not trying to order a baby. I just want to tell you what I?m looking for in a sperm donor. I want somebody who...
From: Munson, Ronald. INTERVENTION AND REFLECTION.6th ED.,Belmont, California: Wadsworth Publishing Company,2000 ., Page 181 Decision Scenario...
From: Munson, Ronald. INTERVENTION AND REFLECTION.6th ED.,Belmont, California: Wadsworth Publishing Company,2000 ., Page 181 Decision Scenario #3 Susan Roth was looking forward to being a mother. She had quit her secretarial job three months before her baby was due so she could spend the time getting everything ready. Her husband, David, was equally enthusiastic, and they spent many hours happily speculating about the way things would be when their baby came. It was their first child. ?I hope they don?t...
Scenario #6 Dr. Daniel McKay and his wife, Carol, had only a few moment of joy...
Scenario #6 Dr. Daniel McKay and his wife, Carol, had only a few moment of joy at the birth of his son. They learned almost immediately that their child was severely impaired. Half an hour later, the infant was dead-Dr. McKay, a veterinarian, had slammed him onto the floor of the delivery room. Mrs. McKay had had problems during pregnancy. An ultrasound test indicated excessive fluid in the uterus, a sign that something might be wrong. Dr. Joaquin Ramos assured...
Scenario #3 Susan Roth was looking forward to being a mother. She had quit her secretarial...
Scenario #3 Susan Roth was looking forward to being a mother. She had quit her secretarial job three months before her baby was due so she could spend the time getting everything ready. Her husband, David, was equally enthusiastic, and they spent many hours happily speculating about the way things would be when their baby came. It was their first child. ?I hope they don?t mix her up with some other baby,? Mrs. Roth said to her husband after delivery....
Scenario 3 The cashier?s office of Archway Memorial Hospital is, even for the wealthy and best...
Scenario 3 The cashier?s office of Archway Memorial Hospital is, even for the wealthy and best educated, a place of frustration. Bills are presented in the form of long computer printouts, covered with unfamiliar names referring to supplies, medical treatment, and diagnostic tests. Associated with each item is a price that seem absurdly high. For someone without medical insurance, being faced with such a bill is more than confusing?it?s frightening. And that was just the situation that Marvin Baldesi found...
Scenario 5 ?Let me see if I understand you correctly,? Mrs. Burgone said. ?I need a...
Scenario 5 ?Let me see if I understand you correctly,? Mrs. Burgone said. ?I need a liver transplant, but I?m not allowed to have such an operation?? ?That?s correct,? Dr. Popp said. ?The National Health policy stipulates that transplant surgery cannot be performed on patients over the age of seventy.? Mrs. Burgone shook her head. ?But I don?t expect National Health to pay for it. I?m able to pay for it myself.? ?That doesn?t matter. It?s a matter of social...
The ad in the newspapers was simple and uninformative: ?Subjects (male and female) wanted to participate...
The ad in the newspapers was simple and uninformative: ?Subjects (male and female) wanted to participate in scientific study. Must be 21 or over. $2 per hour.? Karen Barty wrote down the address. She could use the money, and in 1962, $2 an hour wasn?t bad pay for what was sure to be very little work. Besides, the hours were probably flexible, and she could fit the time into her class The next Tuesday morning at ten o?clock, Karen and...
The Beall Family: Crissy and John Beall are a childless couple who thought they could have...
The Beall Family: Crissy and John Beall are a childless couple who thought they could have a genetic child until they heard about surrogate motherhood. Mrs. Crissy Beall was diagnosed with Cancer of the uterus while in her mid 20’s and had a total hysterectomy. They have asked Dr. Ellis if he would artificially inseminate her widowed Mother (Nancy Hoffman), 51 years old with his husband’s (Mr. John Beall) sperm, so they can have a child that is genetically linked...
How do you relate the most to this story and why? In two strong paragraphs, explain...
How do you relate the most to this story and why? In two strong paragraphs, explain what it is about the tone and/or imagery of the story that speaks to you and why. Use some text examples to support your response Hills Like White Elephants (1927) The hills across the valley of the Ebro1 were long and white. On this side there was no shade and no trees and the station was between two lines of rails in the sun....
Kirby walked into Nancy’s office and said, “I need to talk to you.” He then closed...
Kirby walked into Nancy’s office and said, “I need to talk to you.” He then closed the door and said, “I didn’t appreciate it when you challenged my new production scheduling plan in the meeting. If you had real concerns, why didn’t you wait to talk to me in private? It’s embarrassing to have someone trash my ideas and I don’t want it to happen again.” Nancy, taken by surprise by Kirby’s response replied, “Well, I’m sorry if I embarrassed...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT