Question

Kirby walked into Nancy’s office and said, “I need to talk to you.” He then closed...

Kirby walked into Nancy’s office and said, “I need to talk to you.” He then closed the door and said, “I didn’t appreciate it when you challenged my new production scheduling plan in the meeting. If you had real concerns, why didn’t you wait to talk to me in private? It’s embarrassing to have someone trash my ideas and I don’t want it to happen again.” Nancy, taken by surprise by Kirby’s response replied, “Well, I’m sorry if I embarrassed you. It certainly was not my intention. I just have some strong feelings about the schedule and simply said what I felt. It looked to me that at least two others felt the same way because it seemed to me like they were really biting their tongues when you outlined the plan. Kirby said, “I don’t think that is true. You were the only one who objected to the schedule. Besides your tone indicated that you were dismissing the plan as ridiculous. You are not going to get away with being disrespectful to me.” Nancy then said, “I’m sorry you feel that way. You really caught me by surprise with the plan for the new production schedule.” Kirby then responded, “I will not let you undermine my attempts to improve the way we do things around here. Nancy, you’ve got a bad attitude and you need to change it. If you are that unhappy around here, then you need to leave. We can’t tolerate any people who aren’t cooperative.” Kirby then left. Nancy was in shock over what just happened. She felt terrible about Kirby’s reaction. Just then, Irene stuck her head in the door. She said, “It looks like little Napoleon had another temper tantrum. Was he in here chewing you out?” Nancy said, “Yes, that is what happened. I should have known better than to challenge his ideas in the meeting. I feel just awful.” Irene said, “I know it was no fun for you but I really appreciate the fact that you shot down his idea. Everybody knows that his proposed new schedule would be a disaster. besides, he’s so insecure that even the slightest objection by anybody gets misconstrued as a personal attack. People are afraid to say anything.” Nancy said, “I don’t know what to say any more. We all have more experience than Kirby and have a pretty good idea about what will work with our production facilities. These meetings never go well anymore because we can’t disagree with anything that Kirby wants to do.” Just then Cary walked in and said, ‘Wow! I just saw Kirby walking down the hall from this direction. What did he say to you?” Nancy described the conversation again and Cary said, “That sounds like him. I think that you’d be a great supervisor, but this organization is so male-dominated that even someone like Kirby is tolerated. I know you are upset, but thanks for saying what you did. This new scheduling plan of Kirby’s sounds about as bad as the rest of his ill-conceived ideas. Because we’ve been a good unit in the past and still care about this place, we performance in spite of his incompetence. So it’s not clear to me that upper management knows how bad he is.” Thirty minutes later Kirby went to see his boss, George Master. “George, I’ve had it with Nancy. She’s really got a bad attitude and is poisoning the well with her negativity. Every time I try to introduce a new change, I’ve got to deal with her. I want to start laying a paper trail to get rid of her. She’s got some friends in the department, and they tend to take her side on most things. If we get rid of her, the rest will fall in line.” Questions: How should Kirby have attempted to gain acceptance of his plan for a new production schedule? How should Kirby handle his differences with Nancy? With some of the other associates? What do you think George Masters will want to know about the situation? What advice do you have for Kirby? For Nancy? For George?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Answer:- In my opinion, Kirby should try to look for the acceptance of his plan for a new production schedule with the help of collaboration and communication with the different departments which are involved. By having the acceptance well in advance of the time any kind of conflicts could be overcome by Kirby From the case study it seems that Kirby is suffering from Napoleon complex. In my opinion, Kirby can have the feeling that collaborative overtures might give an impression about his weakness but it is not the case in practicality. In fact, the best solutions can be obtained with the help of collaborative work environment.

Answer:- In my opinion, all the requires steps must be initiated by Kirby and all the required briefing with Nancy must be taken place in order to communicate any sort of possible misunderstandings or issues. While briefing, all the different issues, and factors can be handled effectively

Answer:- George Master will try to understand the reasons behind the hostile enrolment which went out of control and why all the required steps and procedures were not followed from the very beginning. Apart from this, different types of conflict and misunderstanding prevailing among the groups would also be understood by him and the reflection of these issues on the performance of the business.

Answer:- The entire situation must be evaluated completely by Kirby rather than dealing with the situations spontaneously and this can be done by acting in a calm and professional manner.

Nancy should have a lot of sensitive approach towards the team and all the attempts must be made to analyze the reasons behind the feelings of the team members.

George must conduct an official meeting with both the individuals personally in order to analyze the situation and understand it completely so that he can have the right inputs about the breakdown of the situation and guide both the individual for not having any conflicts in future.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Scenario 3 The cashier?s office of Archway Memorial Hospital is, even for the wealthy and best...
Scenario 3 The cashier?s office of Archway Memorial Hospital is, even for the wealthy and best educated, a place of frustration. Bills are presented in the form of long computer printouts, covered with unfamiliar names referring to supplies, medical treatment, and diagnostic tests. Associated with each item is a price that seem absurdly high. For someone without medical insurance, being faced with such a bill is more than confusing?it?s frightening. And that was just the situation that Marvin Baldesi found...
How do you relate the most to this story and why? In two strong paragraphs, explain...
How do you relate the most to this story and why? In two strong paragraphs, explain what it is about the tone and/or imagery of the story that speaks to you and why. Use some text examples to support your response Hills Like White Elephants (1927) The hills across the valley of the Ebro1 were long and white. On this side there was no shade and no trees and the station was between two lines of rails in the sun....
Hello I am currently working on an informative speech for my class. My topic that I...
Hello I am currently working on an informative speech for my class. My topic that I will be speaking on is the importance of budgeting. I am came up with this outline so far: Specific Purpose: To inform the audience about the importance of budgeting - advantages Central Idea: Making a budgeting plan is easy and the most critical step - great tool Introduction Question: what’s more important to you? A daily Starbucks drink or a yearly beach vacation. Why...
(11.1) Here is a case about Jane Jane is a 19-year-old University student who has just...
(11.1) Here is a case about Jane Jane is a 19-year-old University student who has just been transported to the chemical dependency unit at the local hospital. You are asked to do an assessment on her to see if she needs to be admitted for a drug problem or sent to the psychiatric unit for further observation. You meet with Jane and notice that she is barefoot, wearing loose 60's style clothing and her eyes are very dilated. She tells...
Speaking Up in Meetings Barbara J. Krumsiek of the Calvert Group recently talked about the style...
Speaking Up in Meetings Barbara J. Krumsiek of the Calvert Group recently talked about the style of meetings that take place in her organization: I think it can be a little jarring actually for people who are used to perhaps a little more civility. I think we’re civil, but we’re direct. I don’t like meetings if my direct reports leave the room and turn to somebody and say, “Can you believe someone said that?” And so I try to explain...
Question: There could be more than one offer in a scenario and therefore, more than one...
Question: There could be more than one offer in a scenario and therefore, more than one offeror and offeree. In those instances, be specific about which party is the offeror and offeree with each specific offer. Answer The Scenarios Below: Sarah: I will sell you my purse for $100. Sheila: Let me think about it. Sarah: Never mind, I already sold it. Flo: I will sell you my computer for $200. Dale: No way! I am not interested in your...
I quit social media for 1 month -- it was the best choice I ever made...
I quit social media for 1 month -- it was the best choice I ever made I quit social media for a month. So, I quit Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, and Twitter. I just needed a break. It was time to cut myself off I stopped using social media this morning and my brain is going crazy. I just realised how often I glance down just to see if I have a notification. When I wake up in the morning, on...
Read the case below and given the knowledge you have obtained from this case study, what...
Read the case below and given the knowledge you have obtained from this case study, what factors are critical to a professional auditor properly applying professional skeptisim? Case Study A — Not Just a Trivial Item I joined a Big Four accounting firm straight out of college a few years ago as a staff accountant. My first assignment on an audit engagement was a learning experience I would never forget; it was a practical lesson perhaps even more valuable than...
Scenario 7 ?My husband and I have talked over the matter in great detail,? Marge Gower...
Scenario 7 ?My husband and I have talked over the matter in great detail,? Marge Gower said. ?We don?t care about the sex of the child, but we know exactly the kinds of features we want.? ?Mrs. Gower,? Dr. Louise Singh said, ?you?ve got to understand that we?re not running a mail-order-catalog business for babies.? ?I?m not trying to order a baby. I just want to tell you what I?m looking for in a sperm donor. I want somebody who...
Consider the following letter and answer Shady’s question. To my friendly student tax preparer: Hello, my...
Consider the following letter and answer Shady’s question. To my friendly student tax preparer: Hello, my name is Shady Slim. I understand you are going to help me figure out my gross income for the year . . . whatever that means. It’s been a busy year and I’m a busy man, so let me give you the lowdown on my life and you can do your thing. I was unemployed at the beginning of the year and got $2,000...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT