Question

Sam is a business executive who flies often in connection with work. After the September, 2001...

Sam is a business executive who flies often in connection with work. After the September, 2001 terrorists' destruction in New York and Washington, Sam flew less frequently. In response to the attacks, new federal regulations made the federal government responsible for all airport security personnel. In most cases, including at Sam's home airport, the government met the obligation by hiring private contractors to provide the security services. These firms were heavily regulated and controlled by the government. Also, in the new regulations were profiling guidelines that required additional security screenings for persons meeting such guidelines. These guidelines were partly secret, but it was known that members of certain races were much more likely to fall within them. In addition, on average, six times as many males as females met the guidelines. Shortly after these regulations were in place, Sam went to his airport and found extremely long lines at the security checkpoint. He waited in line nearly 3 hours. As he was about 10 people away from being screened, an irate passenger, Marvin, came running through the line screaming that he was about to miss his flight. Marvin accidentally hit Sam forcefully, breaking Sam's arm. In addition, Sam had his pet ferret (a small animal, an exotic pet) in his coat pocket. The impact caused the ferret to die. Marvin said that the slowness and incompetence of the security personnel had caused him to "lose it." When Sam reached the security checkpoint, he was pulled aside for additional screening. This involved waiting in an additional line for 30 minutes longer. Sam learned that he had to go through the additional security because he was returning home on the same day, had no checked baggage, and was male. Sam has sued both the security screening company and Marvin for his injuries and the loss of his ferret, and emotional distress related to these. Discuss Sam's claims, any defenses and their likely resolution.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Sam’s claims would not prevail against the security screening company because they did not breach a duty and because Marvin’s actions would likely be viewed as a superseding event.Sam could prove all the elements of negligence against Marvin for his physical injuries, but the presence of a ferret in his pocket would likely make that consequence unforeseeable.Sam would not be able to recover for emotional distress because his pet would not be considered as a relative. Therefore, he would prevail in the negligence claim except that he would not prevail for the claim related to the ferret.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Tax Return Problem –?Decision Making Alice J. and Bruce M. Byrd are married taxpayers who file...
Tax Return Problem –?Decision Making Alice J. and Bruce M. Byrd are married taxpayers who file a joint return. Their Social Security numbers are 123-45-6789 and 111-11-1112, respectively. Alice's birthday is September 21, 1969, and Bruce's is June 27, 1968. They live at 473 Revere Avenue, Lowell, MA 01850. Alice is the office manager for Lowell Dental Clinic, 433 Broad Street, Lowell, MA 01850 (employer identification number 98-7654321). Bruce is the manager of a Super Burgers fast-food outlet owned and...
Who are the internal and external decision makers for this project analysis?        The phone rang...
Who are the internal and external decision makers for this project analysis?        The phone rang in the office of Jack Smith, an executive at Specialized Medical Devices, Inc. (SMD), a firm that manufactures specialized digital mammography devices. On the line was Dr. Sipparo, Chief of Radiology at Academic Medical Center (AMC). Dr. Sipparo explained that she needed Smith's help in understanding an analysis prepared by the staff of Dr. Alexander, AMC's Chief Executive Officer, of the pending purchase of...
Note: This problem is for the 2018 tax year. Alice J. and Bruce M. Byrd are...
Note: This problem is for the 2018 tax year. Alice J. and Bruce M. Byrd are married taxpayers who file a joint return. Their Social Security numbers are 123-45-6789 and 111-11-1112, respectively. Alice's birthday is September 21, 1971, and Bruce's is June 27, 1970. They live at 473 Revere Avenue, Lowell, MA 01850. Alice is the office manager for Lowell Dental Clinic, 433 Broad Street, Lowell, MA 01850 (employer identification number 98-7654321). Bruce is the manager of a Super Burgers...
Gender Bias in the Executive Suite Worldwide The Grant Thornton International Business Report (IBR) has described...
Gender Bias in the Executive Suite Worldwide The Grant Thornton International Business Report (IBR) has described itself as "a quarterly survey of business leaders from across the globe … surveying 11,500 businesses in 40 economies across the globe on an annual basis." 1 According to the 2011 IBR, the Asia Pacific region had a higher percentage (27 percent) of female chief executive officers (CEOs) than Europe and North America. Japan is the only Asia Pacific region exception. The report further...
Scenario Pigs R Us is a second generation, family-owned Richmond-based company with about 400 employees. It...
Scenario Pigs R Us is a second generation, family-owned Richmond-based company with about 400 employees. It slaughters, manufactures, and sells pork food products.  Pigs R Us (PRU) is a low-tech, hands-on, “bricks and mortar” type of company with solid brand recognition, an impeccable reputation for high quality and ethical standards. The processes used in manufacturing are with the highest ISO20002 standards, and the plant is maintained immaculately. The personnel are comprised of an older work force (average employee age is late...
Scenario Pigs R Us is a second generation, family-owned Richmond-based company with about 400 employees. It...
Scenario Pigs R Us is a second generation, family-owned Richmond-based company with about 400 employees. It slaughters, manufactures, and sells pork food products.  Pigs R Us (PRU) is a low-tech, hands-on, “bricks and mortar” type of company with solid brand recognition, an impeccable reputation for high quality and ethical standards. The processes used in manufacturing are with the highest ISO20002 standards, and the plant is maintained immaculately. The personnel are comprised of an older work force (average employee age is late...
What tools could AA leaders have used to increase their awareness of internal and external issues?...
What tools could AA leaders have used to increase their awareness of internal and external issues? ???ALASKA AIRLINES: NAVIGATING CHANGE In the autumn of 2007, Alaska Airlines executives adjourned at the end of a long and stressful day in the midst of a multi-day strategic planning session. Most headed outside to relax, unwind and enjoy a bonfire on the shore of Semiahmoo Spit, outside the meeting venue in Blaine, a seaport town in northwest Washington state. Meanwhile, several members of...
1. The failure of the new supply chain system affected Nike adversely. What were the reasons...
1. The failure of the new supply chain system affected Nike adversely. What were the reasons for the failure and how did the breakdown harm Nike? 2. What are the important elements to be kept in mind while implementing a new system in an organization? What is the importance of a good working relationship between partners and the sharing of responsibility in implementing critical projects? What mistakes did Nike and i2 make? 3. comment on the lessons learned and the...
Please read the article and answear about questions. Determining the Value of the Business After you...
Please read the article and answear about questions. Determining the Value of the Business After you have completed a thorough and exacting investigation, you need to analyze all the infor- mation you have gathered. This is the time to consult with your business, financial, and legal advis- ers to arrive at an estimate of the value of the business. Outside advisers are impartial and are more likely to see the bad things about the business than are you. You should...
Delta airlines case study Global strategy. Describe the current global strategy and provide evidence about how...
Delta airlines case study Global strategy. Describe the current global strategy and provide evidence about how the firms resources incompetencies support the given pressures regarding costs and local responsiveness. Describe entry modes have they usually used, and whether they are appropriate for the given strategy. Any key issues in their global strategy? casestudy: Atlanta, June 17, 2014. Sea of Delta employees and their families swarmed between food trucks, amusement park booths, and entertainment venues that were scattered throughout what would...