Question

Philosophy: Suppose that a person A saves a child from drowning because she will be rewarded...

Philosophy: Suppose that a person A saves a child from drowning because she will be rewarded for doing so, and suppose another person B saves a child from drowning because he wants to help the child. Discuss whether Rand, Kant, and Mill would think that there is any difference, with respect to moral value, between the actions in these two cases. Critically discuss the bases for their assessment and the main factors that support their judgments. Which position do you think provides the best account of a standard for making moral judgments? Why?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Ayn Rand’s Rational Individualism suggests that Man is a heroic creature with productive achievements that makes him happy.In this case the man who saves the child is a hero who derives happiness from the act of saving a child’s life and this will be his achievement from which he will be satisfied.

Kant’s deontological moral theory proposes the categorical imperative where Kant asks everyone to be exemplary that would be set as a benchmark for others to follow. Before you want others to follow something, you practice it in your life. The man who saved the child’s life set an exemplary act to others that we should save other’s life without being selfish.

Mill’s principle of Utility suggests that the act or utility should bring maximum happiness to maximum people and in this case by saving the child, the man is happy, the child is happy, the child’sfamily is happy and the onlookers are happy.

Although all the concepts, in my point of view, Mill’s view sets the benchmark moral concept because the ultimate aim of life is to be happy and maximum happiness for more number of people is derived from Mill’s Principle of Utility concept.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Team 5 answer the questions What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from...
Team 5 answer the questions What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from reading their paper? How does the topic relate to you and your current or past job? Critique the paper in terms of the organization and quality. Incentive Systems             In this paper, we will focus primarily on financial rewards that companies use to attract, retain and motivate the brightest and most talented candidates in the labor market. By providing a reward system that...
Using the model proposed by Lafley and Charan, analyze how Apigee was able to drive innovation....
Using the model proposed by Lafley and Charan, analyze how Apigee was able to drive innovation. case:    W17400 APIGEE: PEOPLE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AND THE CHALLENGE OF GROWTH Ranjeet Nambudiri, S. Ramnarayan, and Catherine Xavier wrote this case solely to provide material for class discussion. The authors do not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. The authors may have disguised certain names and other identifying information to protect confidentiality. This publication may not be...
Please read the article and answear about questions. Determining the Value of the Business After you...
Please read the article and answear about questions. Determining the Value of the Business After you have completed a thorough and exacting investigation, you need to analyze all the infor- mation you have gathered. This is the time to consult with your business, financial, and legal advis- ers to arrive at an estimate of the value of the business. Outside advisers are impartial and are more likely to see the bad things about the business than are you. You should...
Please answer the following Case analysis questions 1-How is New Balance performing compared to its primary...
Please answer the following Case analysis questions 1-How is New Balance performing compared to its primary rivals? How will the acquisition of Reebok by Adidas impact the structure of the athletic shoe industry? Is this likely to be favorable or unfavorable for New Balance? 2- What issues does New Balance management need to address? 3-What recommendations would you make to New Balance Management? What does New Balance need to do to continue to be successful? Should management continue to invest...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics Enron finds itself in this case. How would you describe the ethical culture and levels of trust at Enron? Provide reasons for your assessment. THE FALL OF ENRON: A STAKEHOLDER FAILURE Once upon a time, there was a gleaming headquarters office tower in Houston, with a giant tilted "£"' in front, slowly revolving in the Texas sun. The Enron Corporation, which once ranked among...
What tools could AA leaders have used to increase their awareness of internal and external issues?...
What tools could AA leaders have used to increase their awareness of internal and external issues? ???ALASKA AIRLINES: NAVIGATING CHANGE In the autumn of 2007, Alaska Airlines executives adjourned at the end of a long and stressful day in the midst of a multi-day strategic planning session. Most headed outside to relax, unwind and enjoy a bonfire on the shore of Semiahmoo Spit, outside the meeting venue in Blaine, a seaport town in northwest Washington state. Meanwhile, several members of...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT