Question

Q3_3From Theory and Practice in Policy Analysis, by M. Granger Morgan. Should policy analysis be more...

Q3_3From Theory and Practice in Policy Analysis, by M. Granger Morgan. Should policy analysis be more like science and avoid value judgments? If so, how do we ensure that it is useful and relevant.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Policy analysis should be like based on Value Judgements. Modern economists have attempted to strip value judgments out of their policy analyses. Policies are judged on how they are likely to affect economic variables such as income and its distribution, and how those changes would affect overall welfare. If the models suggest that one policy choice—a top tax rate of 40%, say, rather than 50%—leads to greater welfare than another, that is usually good enough for an economist.

This approach is enormously valuable. It disciplines thinking, produces useful information and makes it easier to build professional consensus about what is known and which questions remain unanswered. Though cost-benefit analysis is not perfect, is often the best route to getting informed experts to agree.

Used in isolation, however, it can lead to trouble. In a paper presented at the annual conference of the American Economic Association (AEA) in January, Matthew Weinzierl, of Harvard University, notes that the world is too complicated to be modelled with anything like perfect accuracy. Many knock-on effects from policy shifts are unknowable beforehand. He suggests that in the absence of perfect foresight, policymakers could turn to social principles or rules that have evolved over time. These may reflect accumulated knowledge about some choices’ unintended consequences. He gives an example. Governments might choose to increase redistribution based on evidence that high inequality creates feelings of envy, and envy reduces the welfare of the non-rich by making them feel worse. Yet survey evidence suggests that people are largely opposed to redistribution that is motivated by envy. Validating envy through tax policy could prove socially corrosive, in a way that economists’ models fail to capture.

Put differently, Mr Weinzierl contends that economists should take moral concerns more seriously. That is something close to professional heresy. At the AEA conference Alvin Roth, a Nobel prizewinner, delivered a lecture on his life-saving work in the field of market design. To donate an organ, one must share a blood-type with the recipient. Someone who would be willing to donate a kidney to a friend or family member might be stymied by a difference in blood-type. Mr Roth circumvented this problem by developing matching markets, in which one person donates to a compatible stranger and in turn receives another stranger’s compatible organ for use by the donor’s ailing loved-one. Such swap groups can include scores of donors and recipients, who might otherwise have died awaiting a transplant.

Yet demand for healthy organs vastly outstrips supply. Were it legal to buy and sell organs, many more people might donate, helping to alleviate the deadly shortage. Moral qualms generally discourage governments from legalising the trade. This is an example of what Mr Roth calls a “repugnant market”, one which is constrained by popular distaste or moral unease. Repugnance, he laments, tilts the political playing field against ideas that unlock the gains from trade. He recommends that economists spend more time thinking about such taboos, but mostly because they are a constraint on the use of markets in new contexts.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Discuss your point of view ? Theory and Practice in Policy Analysis, Chapter 1 – Most...
Discuss your point of view ? Theory and Practice in Policy Analysis, Chapter 1 – Most people have not spent much time thinking about the approach or perspective we ought to use when making important decisions. A major goal of this class is to teach the perspective and tools of a "policy analyst". This first chapter serves as a bit of an introduction to some of the ideas of how that ought to work, which is actually still being debated....
Point estimates often need to be nested in layers of analysis, and it is the Invariance...
Point estimates often need to be nested in layers of analysis, and it is the Invariance Principle that provides a pathway for doing so. An example would be estimating Mu after having to estimate Alpha and Beta for some distributions. In simpler statistics class exercises (like those we've seen up until now), this is typically avoided by providing the lower level parameters within exercises or problems (e.g. asking you for Mu by giving you the Alpha and Beta). The only...
1.According to Interbrand’s analysis, Apple’s brand is valued at more than $170 billion, while Google in...
1.According to Interbrand’s analysis, Apple’s brand is valued at more than $170 billion, while Google in second place is valued at $120 billion and Coca-Cola in third is at $78 billion (2015). Do you agree that Apple should be so far ahead of its nearest brand competition? What about Samsung, which is larger in size (Samsung is valued at $45 billion)? 2. With Steve Jobs, Apple’s legendary founder and CEO, passing away in 2011, what can we expect from Apple...
Background: Darwinism Today the theory of evolution is a well-supported, unifying principle in biology, which explains...
Background: Darwinism Today the theory of evolution is a well-supported, unifying principle in biology, which explains how life on earth began and developed. The scientific evidence overwhelmingly supports the idea that all living things share a common ancestry. Charles Darwin, a British naturalist, is the person most remembered for his contribution to how the process of evolution works. He wrote a book, published over 150 years ago, called On the Origin of Species, which was very controversial at the time....
An analysis of company performance using DuPont analysis A sheaf of papers in her hand, your...
An analysis of company performance using DuPont analysis A sheaf of papers in her hand, your friend and colleague, Madison, steps into your office and asked the following. MADISON: Do you have 10 or 15 minutes that you can spare? YOU: Sure, I’ve got a meeting in an hour, but I don’t want to start something new and then be interrupted by the meeting, so how can I help? MADISON: I’ve been reviewing the company’s financial statements and looking for...
History: Offer an analysis of the articles included in the following articles: Science Fiction. Do you...
History: Offer an analysis of the articles included in the following articles: Science Fiction. Do you think the article offers a valid interpretation of the content offered in the current or previous chapters? Use an example to support your viewpoint. Minimum 250 words "Why Sci-Fi Keeps Imagining the Subjugation of White People" As much as the genre imagines the future, it also remixes the past—often by envisioning Western-style imperialism visited on the Western world. Science-fiction "contemplates possible futures." So says...
Item Chapter 5 Planning Programs that Prevent Discipline Problems Quote of the Day #1: You can...
Item Chapter 5 Planning Programs that Prevent Discipline Problems Quote of the Day #1: You can discover more about a person in an hour of play than in a year of conversation. Plato This chapter focuses on planning programs that prevent discipline problems. I consider myself a "constructivist teacher". I think students learn best when the information is meaningful to them and the process engages their curiosity and exploration. I want to encourage students to explore ideas and develop them,...
Item 6 In the case below, the original source material is given along with a sample...
Item 6 In the case below, the original source material is given along with a sample of student work. Determine the type of plagiarism by clicking the appropriate radio button. Original Source Material Student Version The theory we have constructed originates with the three phases of learning described above. We have organize and adapted the features of simulations to provide the learner with the most effective and efficient presentations in order to achieve successful acquisition, application and assessment. Our general...
Analysis: This section should include the issue register as a bare minimum, but may include also...
Analysis: This section should include the issue register as a bare minimum, but may include also why-why diagrams, a Pareto chart, a waste table and/or value-added analysis table. Flow analysis or simulation of this case study might be possible but might require making a lot of assumptions given the provided data. The first part of the project: Introduction    Walmart has continued to retain the top position on the Fortune 500 list for a consecutive fifth year. The brand has...
After listening to this podcast, list and discuss the safe injection practices you should follow to...
After listening to this podcast, list and discuss the safe injection practices you should follow to prevent causing harm. Protecting Patients from Unsafe Injections: What Every Provider Needs to Know [Announcer] This program is presented by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. [Joyanna Wendt] Hello. I’m Dr. Joyanna Wendt, a Medical Officer at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or CDC, and today we’re talking about injection safety. I know some of you are thinking, “That’s so basic....
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT