Question

A financial analyst has recently argued that portfolio managers who rely on asset allocation techniques spend...

A financial analyst has recently argued that portfolio managers who rely on asset allocation techniques
spend too much time trying to estimate expected returns on different classes of securities and not enough
time on estimating the correlations between their returns. The correlations are important, he argues,
because a change in correlation, even with no change in expected returns, can lead to changes in the
optimal portfolio. In particular, he argues that as the correlation between stock and bond returns ranges
from 0.2 to 0.6, “the allocation to stocks remains fairly constant…but there are major asset shifts between
cash and bonds”.
See if you can illustrate this point with the following example: A portfolio manager is considering three
categories assets: stocks, bonds and cash. The expected returns, E(r), and standard deviations of returns
for these assets are as follows:
E(r) Std. Dev.
Stock 0.14 0.17
Bonds 0.10 0.09
Cash 0.08
The average degree of risk aversion of the portfolio’s clients is A= 4.
(a) What is the optimal complete portfolio composition if the correlation between stock and bond returns
is 0.2? (10 points)
(b) What is the optimal complete portfolio composition if the correlation between stock and bond returns
is 0.6? (10 points)
(c) Are your answers to (a) and (b) consistent with the analyst’s point? How would you explain what is
happening as we move from the conditions in part (a) to those of part (b)? (10 points)

Homework Answers

Answer #1

(a) The utility factor U is given by

U = E(p) - 0.5*A*Sd(p)*Sd(p)

Where E(p) is the expected return on the portfolio and Sd(p) is the standard deviation of the portfolio

An investor tries to maximize this function.

For finding the optimal complete portfolio, we use an excel solver.

The expected return on the portfolio is the weighted average of the individual asset returns. The standard deviation is found using the formula (as calculated)

Here, cash is considered to be risk-free asset

We set the solver to maximize the utility function

Solving, we get

Weight in Stock Weight in Bond Weight at cash Expected return Standard deviation
47.26% 43.88% 8.87% 0.11713 9.635%
Utility function 0.098564797

b) If the correlation between stock and bond returns is 0.6

Setting the correlation = 0.6 and the same excel parameter as in part a), we get

Weight in Stock Weight in Bond Weight at cash Expected return Standard deviation
50.46% 4.54% 45.00% 0.11118 8.830%
Utility function 0.095592294

c)

As we move from part a) to part b), the correlation coefficient between stock and bond increases from 0.2 to 0.6

Yes, the answers are consistent with the analyst's point.

Here,as we observe that the expected return is about same ~11-11.7% in both the cases. The weight in stocks also remains fairly similar `47%-50%

However, similar to the analyst's say that there would be major major asset shifts between cash and bonds we observe that the weight in bonds decreases from ~44% to 4.5% and the weight of cash in the portfolio increases from ~9% to 45%.

As they move from part a to part b, the correlation between stock and bond increases. Due to this, for the same allocation weights, the overall risk, and hence the utility for the investor decreases. Lower the correlation, lower the risk, and hence higher the utility function. As correlation increases, more weight is given to cash as more overlapping between bond and stock leads to higher risk.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Consider the following capital market: a risk-free asset yielding 2.75% per year and a mutual fund...
Consider the following capital market: a risk-free asset yielding 2.75% per year and a mutual fund consisting of 65% stocks and 35% bonds. The expected return on stocks is 13.25% per year and the expected return on bonds is 4.75% per year. The standard deviation of stock returns is 42.00% and the standard deviation of bond returns 14.00%. The stock, bond and risk-free returns are all uncorrelated. What is the expected return on the mutual fund? What is the standard...
Consider the following capital market: a risk-free asset yielding 2.25% per year and a mutual fund...
Consider the following capital market: a risk-free asset yielding 2.25% per year and a mutual fund consisting of 80% stocks and 20% bonds. The expected return on stocks is 13.25% per year and the expected return on bonds is 3.95% per year. The standard deviation of stock returns is 40.00% and the standard deviation of bond returns 14.00%. The stock, bond and risk-free returns are all uncorrelated. a. What is the expected return on the mutual fund?  11.39 b. What is...
When adding real estate to an asset allocation program that currently includes only stocks, bonds, and...
When adding real estate to an asset allocation program that currently includes only stocks, bonds, and cash, which of the properties of real estate returns affect portfolio risk? (Select all that apply.) i. Standard deviation. ii. Expected return. iii. Correlation with returns of the other asset classes.
Asset Expected Return Standard Deviation Risky debt 6% 0.25 Equity 10% .60 Riskless debt 4.5% 0...
Asset Expected Return Standard Deviation Risky debt 6% 0.25 Equity 10% .60 Riskless debt 4.5% 0 The coefficient of correlation between the returns on the risky debt and equity is 0.72 2A. Using the Markowitz portfolio optimization method, what would the composition of the optimal risky portfolio of these assets be? 10 points 2B. What would the expected return be on this optimal portfolio? 2 points 2C. What would the standard deviation of this optimal portfolio be? 3 points
5. Variance Covariance Matrix and Asset Allocation Model (Markowitz Portfolio Model): Suppose the variance covariance matrix...
5. Variance Covariance Matrix and Asset Allocation Model (Markowitz Portfolio Model): Suppose the variance covariance matrix for two stocks is given as: Stock 1 Stock 2 Stock 1 0.025 0.015 Stock 2 0.030 The expected rate of returns on Stocks 1 and 2 are 10% and 12%, respectively. The average return to risk-free treasury is 5%. Given that the objective of the investor is a minimum-risk portfolio, find the optimum weights of each stock in the portfolio.
Asset Expected Return Standard Deviation Risky debt 6% 0.25 Equity 10% .60 Riskless debt 4.5% 0...
Asset Expected Return Standard Deviation Risky debt 6% 0.25 Equity 10% .60 Riskless debt 4.5% 0 The coefficient of correlation between the returns on the risky debt and equity is 0.72 2A. Using the Markowitz portfolio optimization method, what would the composition of the optimal risky portfolio of these assets be? Please show work
You are constructing a portfolio of two assets, Asset A and Asset B. The expected returns...
You are constructing a portfolio of two assets, Asset A and Asset B. The expected returns of the assets are 10 percent and 16 percent, respectively. The standard deviations of the assets are 27 percent and 35 percent, respectively. The correlation between the two assets is .37 and the risk-free rate is 5.4 percent. What is the optimal Sharpe ratio in a portfolio of the two assets? What is the smallest expected loss for this portfolio over the coming year...
a) Michael has a portfolio comprising 2 assets: Stock X and Stock Y. Probability distribution of...
a) Michael has a portfolio comprising 2 assets: Stock X and Stock Y. Probability distribution of returns on Stock X and Stock Y are as follows Bear market Normal market Bull market Probability 0.2 0.5 0.3 Stock X -20% 18% 50% Stock Y -15% 20% 10% i)            What are the expected rates of return for Stocks X and Y? ii)           What are the standard deviations of returns on Stocks X and Y? ( b) You are a fund manager responsible for a...
Risk and Return Suppose that the entire security market is made of only three types of...
Risk and Return Suppose that the entire security market is made of only three types of assets: a risk-free asset, with a return of 3%, and two risky stocks A and B. There are 500 A stocks trading in the market, at a price of $10 per stock. Stock A has an expected return of 8% and a volatility of 10%. There are 375 B stocks trading in the market at a price of $8 per stock. Stock B has...
Suppose Asset A has an expected return of 10% and a standard deviation of 20%. Asset...
Suppose Asset A has an expected return of 10% and a standard deviation of 20%. Asset B has an expected return of 16% and a standard deviation of 40%. If the correlation between A and B is 0.35, what are the expected return and standard deviation for a portfolio consisting of 30% Asset A and 70% Asset B? Plot the attainable portfolios for a correlation of 0.35. Now plot the attainable portfolios for correlations of +1.0 and −1.0. Suppose a...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT