Question

Suppose there is an inexpensive screening test ($20) with a lot of false positives (individuals test...

Suppose there is an inexpensive screening test ($20) with a lot of false positives (individuals test positive but don’t have cancer), and a more expensive test ($500) that is always accurate. Consider two strategies for screening 1000 people. Strategy A. Everyone gets the inexpensive test, which is then repeated on everyone who tests positive the first time. Those who test positive both times get the expensive test. Strategy B. Everyone gets the inexpensive test, and all who test positive get the expensive test. You will need this additional information: 20% of the population tests positive the first time on the inexpensive test. Of those who test positive, 50% would test positive again if that test is repeated. Of those who test positive both times, 20% have cancer. Of those who test positive the first time but would not the second time, only 2% have cancer. [Note: this information is sufficient to determine how many cancers will be detected under each strategy. Strategy A will detect all of the cancers that exist among those who test positive twice by the inexpensive test. Strategy B will detect all of the cancers that exist among those who test positive the first time.] a. Using these numbers only, what are the average costs per cancer found under Strategy A and Strategy B? b. Compared with a third strategy which is no screening and no cancer found, what are the appropriately defined ICERs (Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratios) for Strategy A and Strategy B, measuring effectiveness by number of cancers found? c. Comment on the difference between your answers to part a and part b. d. Could Strategy B ever be considered cost-effective?

Homework Answers

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
A) Sequential screening is performed to reduce the number of false-positives whereby persons who test positive...
A) Sequential screening is performed to reduce the number of false-positives whereby persons who test positive on the first screening test are re-tested a second time. A county-level screening program was implemented whereby 1000 persons were tested for a viral disease in sequence using the same test. The prevalence of the viral disease at the county-level is 15%. The test has a sensitivity of 90% and specificity of 95%. Calculate the PPV (positive predictive value) of persons who undergo both...
Mammograms are a relatively inexpensive and nonintrusive way to test for breast cancer. Suppose that mammogram...
Mammograms are a relatively inexpensive and nonintrusive way to test for breast cancer. Suppose that mammogram screenings are 93% specific and 87% sensitive. This means that those without breast cancer test negative 93% of the time and those with breast cancer test positive 87% of the time. Answer the following questions as if 12.6% of all women have breast cancer. a) Given that a women tests negative, what is the probability that she has breast cancer? (b) Given that a...
Suppose that a screening test for breast cancer has 95% sensitivity and 90% specificity. Assume 1%...
Suppose that a screening test for breast cancer has 95% sensitivity and 90% specificity. Assume 1% of the population being screened truly has breast cancer. a. If you really do have breast cancer, what is the probability that the test says you do? b. If you really do not have breast cancer, what is the probability that the test says you do? c. The screening test is applied to a total of 15 people; 5 who really do have cancer...
Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) test is a common screening test used for detecting prostate cancer. From Harvard...
Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) test is a common screening test used for detecting prostate cancer. From Harvard Medical School “Prostate Knowledge” webpage. Is PSA reliable? Although PSA testing can help catch prostate cancer at an early stage, having an elevated PSA (generally considered more than 4 ng/ml) doesn’t necessarily mean that a man has cancer. Noncancerous conditions, including benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), or an enlarged prostate, and prostatitis, can raise PSA levels. In fact, studies have shown that about 75% of...
Question 1. The main purpose of screening is to identify symptomatic disease using tests, exams, or...
Question 1. The main purpose of screening is to identify symptomatic disease using tests, exams, or other procedures. True False Question 2. The detectable pre-clinical phase of a disease starts when the disease can be identified by a screening test and ends when the disease produces symptoms. True False Question 3 .Diseases that are appropriate for screening… a. Have serious consequences b. Have a treatment that is more effective at an earlier stage c. Have a detectable preclinical phase that...
Week 11 NUS 213 Health Assessment Bridge Prostate Cancer Please review the following sections Identify: 3...
Week 11 NUS 213 Health Assessment Bridge Prostate Cancer Please review the following sections Identify: 3 things you did not know 2 things that are most important in educating a client 1 thing you would like to know more about American Cancer Society Recommendations for Prostate Cancer Early Detection The American Cancer Society (ACS) recommends that men have a chance to make an informed decision with their health care provider about whether to be screened for prostate cancer. The decision...
The general manager of the Hilton Hotel in Sydney is evaluating an employment screening test for...
The general manager of the Hilton Hotel in Sydney is evaluating an employment screening test for the front office clerical staff. During this evaluation all new clerical employees are given the test. 70% pass the test; the rest fail. At a later time, after the new clerical employees have been working for a while, their performance is evaluated as being satisfactory or unsatisfactory. Historically, 80% of all clerical employees have been found to be satisfactory, and 75% of the satisfactory...
Question 21 Suppose a health insurance company is interested in carrying out an investigation as to...
Question 21 Suppose a health insurance company is interested in carrying out an investigation as to the annual expenditures per household on their healthcare costs. In order to most accurately report their figures, the company decides to ensure “virtual certainty” about their estimates by using a Z value of 3.0 for their calculations. The company conducts a SRS of 843 households and determines the sample average household expenditures on healthcare is $43,257.00. A) Assume the company uses a σ=$879.00. Calculate...
I just need the following questions answers Quantitative Research Designs 101 1. Quantitative research attempts to...
I just need the following questions answers Quantitative Research Designs 101 1. Quantitative research attempts to do which of the following? a. Identify, define and measure factors that contribute to a disorder or disease. b. Examine relationships among factors. c. Evaluate the cost-effectiveness of an intervention. d. All of the above 2. Qualitative and quantitative research designs are appropriate to answer different types of public health questions. Which of the following is NOT an objective of qualitative research? a. To...
1.    Observations are all of the following, as an assessment technique, except a.    completed in informal...
1.    Observations are all of the following, as an assessment technique, except a.    completed in informal and formal (e.g., laboratory) settings b.    useful in providing information that may not be obtained through other assessment techniques c.    difficult to complete under some circumstances d.    useless in providing information that is of clinical relevance 2.    The MMPI-2 is what? a.    an IQ test b.    a projective test c.    an objective test d.    a blood test                            ...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT
Active Questions
  • The earth's magnetic field can affect the electron beam in an oscilloscope or a television tube....
    asked 5 minutes ago
  • The Huntington Boys and Girls Club is conducting a fundraiser by selling chili dinners to go....
    asked 14 minutes ago
  • 2. Please determinate the correctness of the following statements and justify your answers (preferably by examples)....
    asked 19 minutes ago
  • Explain the various methods of intelligence collection, specifically human intelligence and signals intelligence.
    asked 22 minutes ago
  • The provided file has syntax and/or logical errors. Determine the problem and fix the program. using...
    asked 25 minutes ago
  • What new items will you need to replace a failing processor? Select all that apply.   ...
    asked 44 minutes ago
  • A system is to be developed for an airport. When passengers have boarded an aircraft, a...
    asked 52 minutes ago
  • After reading Module 5 PowerPoint 1 - The Philosophy of Human Existance and Health Care Policy,...
    asked 1 hour ago
  • 1. Do you feel play has a place in supporting literacy development in early childhood? Explain...
    asked 1 hour ago
  • How should roles be selected for the Emergency Operations Center (EOC)?  Is seniority less important than experience?...
    asked 1 hour ago
  • Discuss routing issues and solutions namely, count-to-infinity, split horizon, split horizon with poison reverse, and hold-down...
    asked 1 hour ago
  • Find an optimal parenthesization of a matrix-chain product whose sequence of dimensions is〈5,10,3,12,5,50,6〉.
    asked 1 hour ago