Question

In the course of the thesis work, a student develops a new approach for the solution...

In the course of the thesis work, a student develops a new approach for the solution of a problem (here referred to as method B). The current state-of-the-art approach, method A, is well published in the literature and has been applied to a large standard problem set where its average performance was discovered to be (and published in the main paper by the developers as) 7 with a standard deviation of 3 across the different problems in the problem set. In addition to the publication, the developers of method A also provide their code for anyone to be able to experiment with and the student decides to pick a random set of 15 problems from the standard problem set and apply both methods to these problems, resulting in the following performance numbers for method A: {8, 3, 10, 8, 11, 4, 6, 4, 12, 4, 5, 10, 6, 2, 10}, and the following performance numbers for the student’s method B: {9, 5, 9, 10, 15, 4, 7, 4, 12, 7, 8, 10, 6, 4, 12}. Looking at this data, the student discovers that it seems that method B outperforms method A and sets out to prove this using significance testing with a two-tailed 5% significance threshold. Given that both published performance results as well as the student’s experimental results are available, a number of tests can be performed.

Evaluate the results in terms of the hypothesis that method B has a higher performance than method A. List all the steps (and formulas) involved in the test and what the result implies for the significance of the hypothesis.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Null Hypothesis, H0:The mean performances of both the methods are the same (

Alternative Hypothesis,Ha:The mean perfomance of method B is higher that mean performance of method A

Since the two methods are applied on the same data, paired t test can be used

The test statistic is given as

The value of t is 3.4125

The critical value is 1.761

Since the calculated value is greater than the critical value , we reject the null hypothesis and conclude that method B has higher performance than method A at 5% level of significance

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
A statistics instructor measured student attitudes toward a statistics course prior to lectures, at the middle,...
A statistics instructor measured student attitudes toward a statistics course prior to lectures, at the middle, and after the final parts of class. Attitudes were measured on a 16-point scale, with higher scores indicating more positive attitudes toward the statistics course. Student Prior to Lectures At the middle After the Final A 6 5 12 B 4 9 15 C 8 12 13 D 12 11 15 E 5 6 9 Based on the results shown in the table, test...
CHAPTER NINE: One-Population Hypothesis Testing: Perform the five-step hypothesis testing approach for the following problem below,...
CHAPTER NINE: One-Population Hypothesis Testing: Perform the five-step hypothesis testing approach for the following problem below, including an appropriate diagram as illustrated in class. The mean time using the present technology that Donald Co. uses to make widgets takes 12 minutes a widget.  Donald Co. is experimenting with a new method, and conducted a sample by making 30 widgets with the new method.  The sample using the new method obtained a mean of 11.2 minutes per widget, with a sample standard deviation...
A school counselor in a high school would like to try out a new conflict-resolution program...
A school counselor in a high school would like to try out a new conflict-resolution program to reduce aggressiveness in students. She first surveyed 16 students using a 20-item instrument to measure their levels of aggression (on a scale of 0 to 10, with higher numbers meaning higher aggression levels). One month after the conflict resolution program was implemented, the students were given the same survey. The data are listed in the table below. The school counselor/researcher has set the...
Appraisal Approaches There are five techniques for designing evaluations to measure performance. (1) The comparative approach...
Appraisal Approaches There are five techniques for designing evaluations to measure performance. (1) The comparative approach takes the performance of one employee and assesses it side-by-side with the performance of other employees. (2) Evaluations based on the extent to which individuals have certain characteristics or traits desirable for company success fall under the attribute approach. (3) The behavioral approach focuses on the behaviors an employee must exhibit to be effective on the job. (4) Evaluations that concentrate on objective elements...
Part A. In the past it has been found that the arrival time have a population...
Part A. In the past it has been found that the arrival time have a population mean value of μ = 13 and a population standard deviation of σ = 6.26. Using the given data, test whether this mean has changed. Use the critical value approach to test the hypothesis. The significance level alpha is set at 0.05 . The original data of time taken is given below. Show the process by using excel (Formulas). Part B. Test the hypothesis...
In the article “The Eastern Cottonmouth (Agkistrodon piscivorus) at the Northern Edge of Its Range” (Journal...
In the article “The Eastern Cottonmouth (Agkistrodon piscivorus) at the Northern Edge of Its Range” (Journal of Herpetology, Vol. 29, No. 3, pp. 391-398), C. Blem and L. Blem examined the reproductive characteristics of the eastern cottonmouth snake. The data, provided in the attached file, give the number of young per litter for 24 female cottonmouths in Florida and 44 female cottonmouths in Virginia. Preliminary data analyses indicate that you can reasonably presume that the litter sizes of cottonmouths in...
Please follow the above definitions in calculating the quartiles. There are two distinct situations: set size...
Please follow the above definitions in calculating the quartiles. There are two distinct situations: set size equal to a power of 4 (L is already a whole number – integer), set size not a power of 4. Note: each of the following problems is 15 points. PROBLEM 2: Average wait in minutes for the train QM3; n=12 15 4 5 9 6 12 17 10 8 13 8 16 PROBLEM 3: Quiz scores L n = 13 students 5   7  ...
Chapter 11: Using the attached dataset “Chapter 11 Data Set 1” to test the research hypothesis...
Chapter 11: Using the attached dataset “Chapter 11 Data Set 1” to test the research hypothesis that males raise their hands in class more often than females. (Please note that these data are not exactly the data provided by the author). Is this a directional or non-directional hypothesis? Should you use a one-tailed or two-tailed test? What is the corresponding null hypothesis? Conduct the between groups t-test using Excel (either method). Use the .05 confidence level. What is your conclusion...
Chapter 11: Using the attached dataset “Chapter 11 Data Set 1” to test the research hypothesis...
Chapter 11: Using the attached dataset “Chapter 11 Data Set 1” to test the research hypothesis that males raise their hands in class more often than females. (Please note that these data are not exactly the data provided by the author). Is this a directional or non-directional hypothesis? Should you use a one-tailed or two-tailed test? What is the corresponding null hypothesis? Conduct the between groups t-test using Excel (either method). Use the .05 confidence level. What is your conclusion...
Elizabeth is an 8-year-old student with an exceptional working memory ability. Her mother is very proud...
Elizabeth is an 8-year-old student with an exceptional working memory ability. Her mother is very proud and seeks to determine if Elizabeth's working memory is significantly higher than other students her age so she is taken to a cognitive psychologist. Elizabeth is given the reverse digit span test where one is shown a sequence of numbers one at a time (i.e. 3, 6, 4, 7) and they must recite that list backwards (i.e. 7, 4, 6, 3). Elizabeth reachest a...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT