Question

Is Restorative Justice “weak” on crime? How so? Can we overcome that perception? How?

Is Restorative Justice “weak” on crime? How so? Can we overcome that perception? How?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Restorative Justice is a system of criminal justice which focuses on the rehabilitation of offenders through reconciliation with victims and the community at large.

There are mixed sentiments about what restorative justice has come to represent. For some, restorative justice promotes a balanced view of crime as an event affecting a number of different people. A justice practice should therefore encourage the direct involvement of these parties, such as promoting needed dialogue between victim and offender. Where the contemporary justice system does not work well for victims and others, restorative justice promotes needed change. Restorative justice acknowledges that crime is personal: Adherents of this view often suggest that assisting victims, addressing their needs and helping them through their problems, and allowing and encouraging victims to participate in processes and outcomes that affect them, are primary aims of restorative justice. For some victims, working with offenders has been an essential element of their own healing journey.

But the idea of an offender-oriented restorative justice colors other impressions of its practice. Very often, restorative justice not only reflects offender needs— making amends, and changing and rehabilitating offenders—but also is driven by such needs. Restorative justice may be offender initiated, and may be oriented to an offender timeline. Such needs and practices may not be compatible with victim needs, however. Where offenders are provided with help to change their lives, but victims are not provided help to deal with their trauma, victims feel betrayed by the offender orientation of restorative justice.

Restorative justice may also promote unrealistic or unreasonable goals. Where restorative justice appears to go hand-in-hand with expectations for reduced offender penalties, victims may perceive restorative justice as a way out for offenders whose primary motivation might be to avoid responsibility or pain. It is often the expectation of restorative justice programs that offenders will offer genuine apologies for what they have done. But where offenders are not sorry for what they have done, victims may feel harmed again for this failure of justice. Similarly, restorative justice appears to imply that victims are in some sense obligated to assist offenders. This distorts the hope of victims to assist themselves through restorative justice processes. Victim participation for the purpose of offender rehabilitation may be at least an unreasonable burden, if not outright objectionable. Ideas that restorative justice is a panacea are immodest, and without merit.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Criminal Justice: What can crime statistics tell us about the crime picture in America? How has...
Criminal Justice: What can crime statistics tell us about the crime picture in America? How has that picture changed over time?
This week, we covered The CSI Effect. The CSI Effect is a phenomenon in justice administration...
This week, we covered The CSI Effect. The CSI Effect is a phenomenon in justice administration where the exaggerated use of forensic science shown in television programmings such as CSI, Bones, Cold Case, NCIS, Criminal Minds, and other such have impacted the perception and expectation of juries in criminal. As you reflect on this topics, how do you think the CSI Effect affects crime itself. Also, how do you think the CSI effect has or will relate to either your...
Why is conducting a performance appraisal so difficult for managers? How can these difficulties be overcome?
Why is conducting a performance appraisal so difficult for managers? How can these difficulties be overcome?
we discuss urban renewal projects, education and crime in inner cities. What are some advantages and...
we discuss urban renewal projects, education and crime in inner cities. What are some advantages and disadvantages of these projects. Are there any successful ones? What are some ways the educational system in urban areas has improved and/or needs improvement? Is crime actually higher in the inner cities today or is crime decreasing and it is just a perception that crime is worse than ever before? How so?
How does "broken window" theory prevent crime? Note : This question is related to Criminal Justice...
How does "broken window" theory prevent crime? Note : This question is related to Criminal Justice system in america.
How we can use both classical and operant conditioning to overcome the drug dependence?
How we can use both classical and operant conditioning to overcome the drug dependence?
What are the most important qualifications for a salesman? Explain why. How can we overcome objections...
What are the most important qualifications for a salesman? Explain why. How can we overcome objections from customers as a salesman? Explain with examples, please.
What are stereotypes? How can they be beneficial? How can they be detrimental? How can we...
What are stereotypes? How can they be beneficial? How can they be detrimental? How can we overcome stereotypes?
For this week’s discussion, we are going to talk about perceptions and how people can look...
For this week’s discussion, we are going to talk about perceptions and how people can look at the same situation differently. Select and complete one of the perception tests from the links below: Dr. Phil's Personality Test (Links to an external site.) Can you Pass the Perception Test? (Links to an external site.) Visual Perception Personality Test (Links to an external site.) For your initial post, summarize the perception test you completed by answering the below questions: 1. Describe in...
how companies can overcome service variability.
how companies can overcome service variability.