Question

How would a kantian and a utilitarian respond to a woman who tells her dying father...

How would a kantian and a utilitarian respond to a woman who tells her dying father that she will not marry out of her religion, knowing she is lying and will in fact do exactly that?
Social-Sciences   Psychology   
0 0
Add a commentTranscribed image text
Next >

Homework Answers

Answer #1

For Kantian the ethics does not depend upon consequences but it is considered as a duty that should be carried in the same manner everywhere and everytime. So, Kantian:s would disagree to this lying and would respond by stating that woman should not promise her dying father what she cannot keep. They would ask her to say the truth to her father.

Utilitarians prefer pleasure over pain. For them those things that brings more pleasure to one's life than pain should be considered when evaluating a situation for ethics. So, they would support the woman in lying to her father, as they would not want her dying father to be in pain, and would want her father to die in peace which the woman would have intended while making the false promise to her father. Though the utlitarians is against lying but in this context they would favor the woman.

0 0
Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Log In

Sign Up

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
How would a kantian and a utilitarian evaluate the morality of someone in desperate financial need...
How would a kantian and a utilitarian evaluate the morality of someone in desperate financial need who steals money from someone who is wealthy-knowing the wealthy person will never even miss, let alone need, the money?
Your patient is an 82-year-old woman with mild vascular dementia who has fallen and broken her...
Your patient is an 82-year-old woman with mild vascular dementia who has fallen and broken her pelvis. It is a stable fracture and will not be surgically fixed. The physician has ordered physical and occupational therapy and pain management. One family member tells you that because she has dementia she will not need pain medication. Another family member tells you that they do not want her to have pain medication because they are Christian Scientists. 1. What challenges might you...
1.)Describe how you would introduce the topic of dying with a patient who is critically ill...
1.)Describe how you would introduce the topic of dying with a patient who is critically ill and not expected to live. 2.)Describe how you would deal with a dying person and his or her family when they are especially protective of one another.
A medical assistant calls in her patient, an African American transgendered woman (in her late 40s)...
A medical assistant calls in her patient, an African American transgendered woman (in her late 40s) to take a patient history, blood pressure, weight, and other vitals before she sees the physician. The assumption is that she is of middle class economic status. The medical assistant notes in her history that she is in the process of transitioning from male to female and questions the patient’s religious beliefs in relation to her decisions. The patient becomes agitated and expresses to...
Margaret Lockhart is a 42-year-old, never-married woman who lost her job as secretary in a real...
Margaret Lockhart is a 42-year-old, never-married woman who lost her job as secretary in a real estate office a year ago and has not been able to find another job. She has no brothers or sisters and lives with her mother, who is a widow. She has made an appointment at the mental health clinic at the urging of her mother. She is clean and neatly dressed. She appears older than her stated age and has a sad expression. She...
Woman Hollering Creek," Cisneros describes the experiences of an ideal Mexican wife, Cleófilas. Having grown up...
Woman Hollering Creek," Cisneros describes the experiences of an ideal Mexican wife, Cleófilas. Having grown up with her father, six brothers, and no mother, Cleófilas learns how to be a woman by watching telenovelas on television. She learns to expect that passion will fill her life. This passion will be the great love of her life, which will give it direction and meaning, so that "one does whatever one can, must do, at whatever the cost." This, she believes, is...
How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles using a rule utilitarian Scenario...
How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles using a rule utilitarian Scenario #5 Consider the following five cases. Harvey Shick of Tyler, Texas, on June 1, 1983, shot his wife in the head twice with a .22-caliber pistol. Marie Shick had suffered from severe arteriosclerosis since the late 1970s and suffered extreme pain in her lower legs. The couple had been happily married for forty-five years. Although Mr. Shick was charged with murder, the charges were...
say what you liked about this post. Shanara was a warm, compassionate and vibrant woman who...
say what you liked about this post. Shanara was a warm, compassionate and vibrant woman who always went out of her way to help others –no matter what. She was a proud woman who had a passion for life. She had a wonderful sense of humor which endeared her to everyone she met and it is a great testament to her nature that she formed so many long-lasting friendships over the years. So many of you here today. Shanara was...
Claudette is a 35 year old woman who was referred to your health clinic for follow...
Claudette is a 35 year old woman who was referred to your health clinic for follow up care after she spent the night in the Emergency Room with severe stomach cramps and vomiting. She was diagnosed with food poisoning but had elevated blood pressure and revealed to the ER provider that she had not seen a physician for a physical in over ten years. She left the sexual orientation question on her patient self assessment form blank but did report...
MT is a 38 year old woman who was brought in by her husband following a...
MT is a 38 year old woman who was brought in by her husband following a traumatic incident. One week ago, while outside gardening, she witnessed a mid-air collision. She saw two small plans collide and witnessed two bodies thrown from the plane, one of which landed in her yard, about 15 feed away. Marie attempted to call 911 but was paralyzed and blanked out part of the experience. She was found peeling carrots in the kitchen and crying. Since...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT