Question

What is the difference between the first formulation of the Categorical Imperative and the Golden Rule...

What is the difference between the first formulation of the Categorical Imperative and the Golden Rule ('do unto others as you would have them do unto you"; 'treat others the way you want to be treated')? Why, according to Kant, would the Golden Rule insufficient to serve as a rational moral principle of duty?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Kant's Categorical Imperative is a universal, impartial and rational call for doing one's duty. The Categorical Imperative neither encompasses consequences nor desires. It means that actions should not be motivated by any consequences or by any desires to be achieved. The act should be purely impartial, should be carried out in every circumstances and should be according to the moral reasoning of the individual. Thus,morality is carrying out out duties no matter what, and because the maxims of morality is always good, it never produces any harm to others.

The Golden Rule 'do unto others as you would have them do unto you ' ;' treat others the way you want to be treated ' is a give and take concept, that if you want goodness you should give goodness. This rule is bounded by the condition, is capable of producing good but is always motivated for achieving some purpose. If the purpose not met ,then the individual may likely discontinue the action. Also, there are chances that this Golden rule be applied for corrupt self interests.

Hence, the Golden rule as Categorical Imperative is not universal, impartial and rational. Therefore, it is insufficient to serve as a rational moral principle of duty.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Categorical imperative = universal moral law •Formulation 1: Act only on that maxim you could at...
Categorical imperative = universal moral law •Formulation 1: Act only on that maxim you could at the same time will to become universal law. •Formulation 2: Treat humans always as ends in themselves, never as means only. a) Brainstorm an example of an ethical situation (like Kant’s examples of suicide, failing to keep promises, wasting talents, or neglecting others) b) Explain in your own words how BOTH formulations of the categorical imperative require that you act in one way and...
Kant introduces the humanity principle (Act in such a way that you treat humanity, whether in...
Kant introduces the humanity principle (Act in such a way that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or the person of another, always as an end in itself, and never merely as a means) as another formulation of the categorical imperative. This principle, he argues, rests on the dignity of human beings (he argues that human beings are “…objects of respect.” – Kant, p. 36.). Why are human beings, according to Kant, ‘objects of respect’? How does this...
Kant’s famous First Formulation of the Categorical Imperative reads, “Act only according to that maxim whereby...
Kant’s famous First Formulation of the Categorical Imperative reads, “Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law.” Kant taught morality as a matter of following maxims of living that reflect absolute laws. “Universal” is a term that allows for no exceptions, and what is universal applies always and everywhere. Lying, for any reason, is universally wrong. Be sure to listen to the audio simulation in this week's...
Introduction Kant’s famous First Formulation of the Categorical Imperative reads, “Act only according to that maxim...
Introduction Kant’s famous First Formulation of the Categorical Imperative reads, “Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law.” Kant taught morality as a matter of following maxims of living that reflect absolute laws. “Universal” is a term that allows for no exceptions, and what is universal applies always and everywhere. Lying, for any reason, is universally wrong. Be sure to listen to the audio simulation in this...
Team 5 answer the questions What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from...
Team 5 answer the questions What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from reading their paper? How does the topic relate to you and your current or past job? Critique the paper in terms of the organization and quality. Incentive Systems             In this paper, we will focus primarily on financial rewards that companies use to attract, retain and motivate the brightest and most talented candidates in the labor market. By providing a reward system that...
1.Establishing the virtual Management: As known, managing virtual staff requires a different method or approach than...
1.Establishing the virtual Management: As known, managing virtual staff requires a different method or approach than managing local staff. Due to that reason, Golden Scent has developed a strategic plan to successfully manage its virtual staff in the USA. Identify the suitable manager. to make sure our work will proceed as we planned, Golden Scent willrecruit a virtual manager with the essential skills and knowledge required to manage virtual employees. Find the skilled people to work with. Since not everyone...
The assignment summary sheets will be submitted week 14 with Test 3. You are to personally...
The assignment summary sheets will be submitted week 14 with Test 3. You are to personally experience the power and satisfaction of developing these skills firsthand and to reflect and write about this experience. Over the years, many students have shared amazingly rewarding experiences as they worked on these skills. The assignment will be evaluated and be weighted as 5% of your final mark (together, they are worth 20% of your mark for Test 3, which is worth 25% of...
Re word this reflection essay and include more studies on creativity in it. What have I...
Re word this reflection essay and include more studies on creativity in it. What have I Learned? I have learned how to use my brain better, to organize my thinking process in a way to facilitate my perceptions, creativity and innovative thinking methods in a more effective manner. I learned many ideas and findings on how human brain function. For example, according to Tony Buzan, the brain thinks in two ways: association or explosion method. I learned that to change...
The Business Case for Agility “The battle is not always to the strongest, nor the race...
The Business Case for Agility “The battle is not always to the strongest, nor the race to the swiftest, but that’s the way to bet ’em!”  —C. Morgan Cofer In This Chapter This chapter discusses the business case for Agility, presenting six benefits for teams and the enterprise. It also describes a financial model that shows why incremental development works. Takeaways Agility is not just about the team. There are product-management, project-management, and technical issues beyond the team’s control. Lean-Agile provides...
Actually a HISTORY question: what tactics does Einhard use to portray Charlemagne in "Life of Charlemagne"...
Actually a HISTORY question: what tactics does Einhard use to portray Charlemagne in "Life of Charlemagne" and what tactics does Procipius use to describe Justinian in a positive light in the "Nika Riots"? Ive posted both excerpts. "Life of Charlemagne" Charles the Great, (Charlemagne in French) reigned 768-814 as king of the Franks and the most important ruler of the Carolingian Dynasty, conquering lands in what is now Germany, France, Spain, and Italy. On Christmas Day 800 C.E., Pope Leo...