Question

In his commentary on "Cancer and Maybe a Baby?" Ezekiel Emanuel suggests that Mary's physician should...

In his commentary on "Cancer and Maybe a Baby?" Ezekiel Emanuel suggests that Mary's physician should not simply take her expressed wishes as her actual wishes in the name of autonomy. Why might someone think that Mary's autonomy is impaired in this case? Do you agree?

Social-Sciences   Psychology   
0 0
Add a commentTranscribed image text
Next >

Homework Answers

Answer #1

"Mary's physician should not simply take her expressed wishes as her actual wishes in the name of autonomy. The physician must work with Mary to make sure she knows what she wants and that what she wants forms a consistent life vision. This is what autonomy truly means and this is what is required of the compassionate physician." is what Emanuel suggests in the text "Cancer and maybe baby".

It can be seen that Mary's autonomy is impaired here because, Mary and her husband Jason have always wanted to start a family. But now they are thinking- when facing a potentially fatal illness many people, especially young people, consider how they might leave a permanent mark on the world.

It is not just their dream but has become their desire which is driving both- Mary and Jason crazy to have a child but they are unable to understand the complication it could cause to Mary.

0 0
Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Log In

Sign Up

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Read the following case study Competency and End Stage Cancer You have just been consulted, in...
Read the following case study Competency and End Stage Cancer You have just been consulted, in your role as health care administrator, about a case that's happening in the oncology wing. The doctor has phoned you because he knows you have experience about informed consent and decision-making capacity from your MHA program. The patient, Eric, is a 32-year-old male with melanoma that has metastasized to both his brain and his throat. The chemotherapy and radiation are no longer working and...
write 3-5 sentences response to this post in your own words . I believe that active...
write 3-5 sentences response to this post in your own words . I believe that active voluntary euthanasia is morally permissible as long as it is, in fact, voluntary (I also find active nonvoluntary euthanasia permissible as long as a trusted decision-maker is present). In some cases, I would actually prefer it to passive euthanasia because it would be quicker and (as far as we know) not painful for the patient. In the case of brain death or in other...
Scenario #6 Dr. Daniel McKay and his wife, Carol, had only a few moment of joy...
Scenario #6 Dr. Daniel McKay and his wife, Carol, had only a few moment of joy at the birth of his son. They learned almost immediately that their child was severely impaired. Half an hour later, the infant was dead-Dr. McKay, a veterinarian, had slammed him onto the floor of the delivery room. Mrs. McKay had had problems during pregnancy. An ultrasound test indicated excessive fluid in the uterus, a sign that something might be wrong. Dr. Joaquin Ramos assured...
Jim Watanabe was in his new car, driving down I-5, on his way to work. He...
Jim Watanabe was in his new car, driving down I-5, on his way to work. He dreaded the phone call he knew he was going to have to make. The original go-live date for a pilot implementation of Petrie Electronics’ new customer relationship management (CRM) system was July 31. That was only six weeks away, and Jim knew there was no way they were going to be ready. The XRA CRM they were licensing turned out to be a lot...
APPALACHIAN CASE STUDY #1 William Kapp, aged 55 years, and his wife, Gloria, aged 37, have...
APPALACHIAN CASE STUDY #1 William Kapp, aged 55 years, and his wife, Gloria, aged 37, have recently moved from an isolated rural area of northern Appalachia to Denver, Colorado, because of Gloria’s failing health. Mrs. Kapp has had pulmonary tuberculosis for several years. They decided to move to New Mexico because they heard that the climate was better for Mrs. Kapp’s pulmonary condition. For an unknown reason, they stayed in Denver, where William obtained employment making machine parts. The Kapp’s...
The Case Opens On a warm, sunny day in late October, Chip Puller parks his car...
The Case Opens On a warm, sunny day in late October, Chip Puller parks his car and walks into his office at Central Pacific University. It feels good to be starting as a systems analyst, and he is looking forward to meeting the other staff. In the office, Anna Liszt introduces herself. “We’ve been assigned to work as a team on a new project. Why don’t I fill you in with the details, and then we can take a tour...
To complete each assignment, you will need to read the case study. Assume that the client...
To complete each assignment, you will need to read the case study. Assume that the client described in each case study meets criteria for a DSM-5 disorder. You will then consult the DSM-5 criteria and write 1-2 detailed paragraphs in which you assign a primary diagnosis for the client and justify that diagnosis. In this section you should reference EACH of the DSM-5 criteria for the diagnosis you are assigning and provide evidence from the case study for or against...
Mini case: CHECKING IT OUT When Arlene Ryan inherited $250,000 from her grandfather, she decided to...
Mini case: CHECKING IT OUT When Arlene Ryan inherited $250,000 from her grandfather, she decided to use the money to start her own business. Arlene has been a legal secretary for 14 years and feels she knows quite a lot about business. “Every day I take depositions and type legal memoranda,” she noted to a friend. “And I’ve seen lots of businesses fail because they didn’t have adequate capital or proper management. Believe me, when you work for a law...
Part V – CT Scans “Here is your CT scan, Frank. Just to orient you, it...
Part V – CT Scans “Here is your CT scan, Frank. Just to orient you, it shows a slice across your abdoment just below your diaphragm (inset on right). This scan (Figure 2) is taken from a healthy individual; we use it in teaching and you can see labels on the various organs. Now look at your scan (Figure 3), which was taken at a similar plane. I have drawn arrows to show your pancreas,” explained the doctor. “My pancreas...
Case Study: After a very successful career as a professional cyclist, James was forced to retire...
Case Study: After a very successful career as a professional cyclist, James was forced to retire after recovering from a major health scare. Even though his health was compromised, James’ passion for staying connected with the professional cycling community was still strong. So, he decided to establish BRU to leverage his professional cycling network as well as his firsthand knowledge of the deficiencies in existing bicycle technology. Along with his two long-time training partners, John and Marie, James established BRU....
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT