Question

Construct an argument against divine command theory

Construct an argument against divine command theory
Social-Sciences   Psychology   
0 0
Add a commentTranscribed image text
Next >

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Divine command theory is a meta-ethical theory. It is also called theological voluntarism. According to it, the morally good action is similar to action commanded by God.

The argument against Divine Command Theory (DCT), formalized by Web Morriston is given below.

1. Divine command Theory says that whatever God command is obligatory (morally).

2. God can command action Y.

3. So, if Devine command theory is true Y could be obligatory(morally).

4. But Y cannot be obligatory(morally).

Hence, Divine command theory is false. (Morriston 251).

0 0
Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Log In

Sign Up

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
To what extend do you believe that Jews, Christians, and Muslims use the “Divine Command Theory”...
To what extend do you believe that Jews, Christians, and Muslims use the “Divine Command Theory” approach rather than egoism or act or rule utilitarianism as a basis for their ethical systems?
Economic theory suggests that the "unfair competition" argument against unrestricted international trade is generally not valid,...
Economic theory suggests that the "unfair competition" argument against unrestricted international trade is generally not valid, that this argument is likely to be used by domestic producers even if imports benefit the domestic economy as a whole. True False
How to use command line argument in python to write a program implement linux command 'find'?
How to use command line argument in python to write a program implement linux command 'find'?
Unix / Linux 11. Globbing (filename substitution): Provide an argument to the ls command that will...
Unix / Linux 11. Globbing (filename substitution): Provide an argument to the ls command that will result in a globbing expression that meets the following description: Filenames that have a length of 5 characters. 12. Globbing (filename substitution): Provide an argument to the ls command that will result in a globbing expression that meets the following description: Filenames that begin with an alpha and end with a digit. 13. Globbing (filename substitution): Provide an argument to the ls command that...
4. What is one argument for and one argument against NAFTA?
4. What is one argument for and one argument against NAFTA?
Provide one argument for and one argument against further deregulation of banking.
Provide one argument for and one argument against further deregulation of banking.
What is Callahan’s strongest argument against allowing the legalization of euthanasia? Evaluate that argument.
What is Callahan’s strongest argument against allowing the legalization of euthanasia? Evaluate that argument.
Explain/discuss why Phillips thinks that the ethical theory: "autonomy", does not provide a very strong argument...
Explain/discuss why Phillips thinks that the ethical theory: "autonomy", does not provide a very strong argument against manipulative advertising.
Describe one argument for and one argument against foreign aid as an important driver of economic...
Describe one argument for and one argument against foreign aid as an important driver of economic growth.
The argument against the existence of God that Mackie admits fails: (A) the argument from queerness...
The argument against the existence of God that Mackie admits fails: (A) the argument from queerness (B) the evidential problem of evil (C) Pascal’s Wager (D) the argument from disagreement (E) the logical problem of evil
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT