Question

please answer with short verbal comment: can Schrodinger's equation have real wave functions psi(x,t) as solutions?

please answer with short verbal comment:
can Schrodinger's equation have real wave functions psi(x,t) as solutions?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Suppose   is real. Then the energy is given by

or the energy is:

Since is real, its time derivative will also be real. Therefore the energy will be imaginary because of the factor of i in the above equation. But the energy cannot be imaginary. Hence cannot be real.

Note that however, the time-independent part of the wavefunction can be real. The full wave function which includes time dependance cannot be real.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
please answer with short verbal comment would psi(x) = Ae^-ax^2 be an acceptable time independent quantum...
please answer with short verbal comment would psi(x) = Ae^-ax^2 be an acceptable time independent quantum mechanics wave function? (A and a are both real, positive constants) why or why not?
Determine whether each of the following functions is a solution of wave equation: a) u(x, t)...
Determine whether each of the following functions is a solution of wave equation: a) u(x, t) = sin (x − at), b) u(x, t) = sin (x − at) + ln (x + at)
Consider the following wave function: Psi(x,t) = Asin(2piBx)e^(-iCt) for 0<x<1/2B Psi(x,t) = 0 for all other...
Consider the following wave function: Psi(x,t) = Asin(2piBx)e^(-iCt) for 0<x<1/2B Psi(x,t) = 0 for all other x where A,B and C are some real, positive constants. a) Normalize Psi(x,t) b) Calculate the expectation values of the position operator and its square. Calculate the standard deviation of x. c) Calculate the expectation value of the momentum operator and its square. Calculate the standard deviation of p. d) Is what you found in b) and c) consistent with the uncertainty principle? Explain....
Please answer with a short comment: If a single electron in a quantum well has 50%...
Please answer with a short comment: If a single electron in a quantum well has 50% probability to be in the ground state and 50% probability to be in the first excited state, which value(s) will a measurement of the energy produce? What will happen if the measurement is repeated? How can you express the wave function in Dirac notation?
Verify that u(x, t) = v(x + ct) + w(x − ct) satisfies the wave equation...
Verify that u(x, t) = v(x + ct) + w(x − ct) satisfies the wave equation for any twice differentiable functions v and w.
Suppose u(t,x) and v(t,x ) is C^2 functions defined on R^2 that satisfy the first-order system...
Suppose u(t,x) and v(t,x ) is C^2 functions defined on R^2 that satisfy the first-order system of PDE Ut=Vx, Vt=Ux, A.) Show that both U and V are classical solutions to the wave equations  Utt= Uxx. Which result from multivariable calculus do you need to justify the conclusion. B)Given a classical sol. u(t,x) to the wave equation, can you construct a function v(t,x) such that u(t,x), v(t,x) form of sol. to the first order system.
If x1(t) and x2(t) are solutions to the differential equation x"+bx'+cx = 0 1. Is x=...
If x1(t) and x2(t) are solutions to the differential equation x"+bx'+cx = 0 1. Is x= x1+x2+c for a constant c always a solution? (I think No, except for the case of c=0) 2. Is tx1 a solution? (t is a constant) I have to show all works of the whole process, please help me!
A wave on a string can be described by the following equation: y(x,t)=9.2cos(4.2x+0.85t) where y and...
A wave on a string can be described by the following equation: y(x,t)=9.2cos(4.2x+0.85t) where y and x are in meters and t is in seconds. 1) What is the speed of the wave? 0.79 m/s 1.27 m/s 0.2 m/s 4.94 m/s 0.03 m/s 2) What is its wavelength? 0.2 m 0.67 m 7.39 m 5.34 m 1.5 m 3) What is the acceleration of the string in the y direction at x=1.7 m and t=7 seconds? 3.91 m/s2 7.97 m/s2...
Please show all steps, thank you! a) Verify that the functions below solve the system: x(t)...
Please show all steps, thank you! a) Verify that the functions below solve the system: x(t) = c1e^5t + c2e^-t y(t) = 2c1e^5t - c2e^-t Do not solve the system dx/dt = x + 2y dy/dt = 4x +3y b) Solve the system using Operator D elimination. Write the answer both in scalar and vector form. Please show all steps! dx/dt = x + 2y dy/dt = 4x + 3y
Can someone answer why x-vt describes a wave traveling to the right, and x+vt to the...
Can someone answer why x-vt describes a wave traveling to the right, and x+vt to the left? I UNDERSTAND THE MATHEMATICAL DERIVATION OF IT. Please don’t give me a long proof. It does not clarify anything. x-vt is similar to adding a negative velocity, one with velocity going left, therefore the position would become more negative (more left), so why is this descriptive of something going to the right? Example: if I’m +5m from the origin, and I am going...