Question

Dalia worked on a contract basis as an auto mechanic for the clients of an auto...

Dalia worked on a contract basis as an auto mechanic for the clients of an auto repair shop. Whenever there was too much work for the employees of the shop, Dalia would receive a call and be assigned by the shop to do specific repairs on a particular vehicle.

Dalia’s specialty was rebuilding engines and the firm would often contact her to handle complex breakdowns for which they did not have sufficient time, since she worked much faster than the other four mechanics it had on staff. When the job was completed, she was paid a commission for her work based on the amount charged to that client by the auto shop. This commission was established in advance in the contract Dalia was offered when she accepted the position.

During the time she was working, Dalia was paid weekly, was free to use the shop’s garage, and also could use whatever equipment and supplies were necessary to complete the job. In order to ensure a consistent quality among all of its workers, as well as to be sure that it complied with all regulations that might govern the job, the firm’s head mechanic would check the car before the client was called to pick up the vehicle. This process ensured that clients saw all of the shop’s workers and contractors as equivalent quality.

Dalia is laid off in the middle of a job and she files for unemployment compensation. The shop defends the claim, arguing that she was not an employee.

Was Dalia an employee or an independent contractor? Explain.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Dalia was an independent contractor, not an employee, because it is not mentioned in the above stated case that Dalia received any employee-type benefits (such as insurance, pension plan, vacation pay, or sick pay) from the shop. And it is also mentioned in the case that after Dalia does her work, the head mechanic check the vehicle before giving it to the client. A independent contractor is likely to be working with the organization because of their expertise in specific area, like Dalia has in rebuilding engines. As it is also not mentioned in the case that, she was invited by the company in social events and receive all company’s internal communication. From these above mentioned points it is clear that Dalia was a independent contractor, instead of an employee.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Joe operates a business that locates and purchases specialized assets for clients, among other activities. Joe...
Joe operates a business that locates and purchases specialized assets for clients, among other activities. Joe uses the accrual method of accounting but he doesn’t keep any significant inventories of the specialized assets that he sells. Joe reported the following financial information for his business activities during year 0. Determine the effect of each of the following transactions on the taxable business income. (Select "No Effect" from the dropdown if no change in the taxable business income.) Required: Joe has...
Joe operates a business that locates and purchases specialized assets for clients, among other activities. Joe...
Joe operates a business that locates and purchases specialized assets for clients, among other activities. Joe uses the accrual method of accounting but he doesn’t keep any significant inventories of the specialized assets that he sells. Joe reported the following financial information for his business activities during year 0. Determine the effect of each of the following transactions on the taxable business income. (Select "No Effect" from the dropdown if no change in the taxable business income.) a. Joe has...
Background Sarah’s project had now become more complex than she had anticipated. Sarah’s company had a...
Background Sarah’s project had now become more complex than she had anticipated. Sarah’s company had a philosophy that the project manager would be assigned during proposal preparation, assist in the preparation of the proposal, and take on the role of the project manager after contract award, assuming the company would be awarded the contract. Usually, contract go-ahead would take place within a week or two after contract award. That made project staffing relatively easy for most of the project managers....
CASE STUDY Background Sarah’s project had now become more complex than she had anticipated. Sarah’s company...
CASE STUDY Background Sarah’s project had now become more complex than she had anticipated. Sarah’s company had a philosophy that the project manager would be assigned during proposal preparation, assist in the preparation of the proposal, and take on the role of the project manager after contract award, assuming the company would be awarded the contract. Usually, contract go-ahead would take place within a week or two after contract award. That made project staffing relatively easy for most of the...
Background Sarah’s project had now become more complex than she had anticipated. Sarah’s company had a...
Background Sarah’s project had now become more complex than she had anticipated. Sarah’s company had a philosophy that the project manager would be assigned during proposal preparation, assist in the preparation of the proposal, and take on the role of the project manager after contract award, assuming the company would be awarded the contract. Usually, contract go-ahead would take place within a week or two after contract award. That made project staffing relatively easy for most of the project managers....
Jayla just landed an internship with Acme Incorporated in the payroll department. She was excited because...
Jayla just landed an internship with Acme Incorporated in the payroll department. She was excited because these internships usually turned into a full time job after graduation. Jayla was hired by Deon, the head of the Payroll Department. He told her about their policies and stressed the need for maintaining strict confidentiality regarding employee salaries and pay scales. “Several years ago we had an intern who violated the confidentiality policy and was given a negative internship summary,” explained Deon. “I...
ng a Contract Assignment ? INTRODUCTION: As a business owner and/or employer, you will need to...
ng a Contract Assignment ? INTRODUCTION: As a business owner and/or employer, you will need to draft, prepare and negotiate contracts with other businesses, employees, and independent contractors. While you may need to retain an attorney for many contracts, you should have a basic understanding of what clauses to include (and why) in various types of contracts. In this assignment, you will use the knowledge and information you have learned in this course to draft a general contract “checklist” as...
Muffler Magic* Muffler Magic is a fast-growing chain of 25 automobile service centers in Nevada. Originally...
Muffler Magic* Muffler Magic is a fast-growing chain of 25 automobile service centers in Nevada. Originally started 20 years ago as a muffler repair shop by Ronald Brown, the chain expanded rapidly to new locations, and as it did so Muffler Magic also expanded the services it provided, from muffler replacement to oil changes, brake jobs, and engine repair. Today, one can bring an automobile to a Muffler Magic shop for basically any type of service, from tires to mufflers...
CASE STUDY REWARD ENCOURAGES BEAST.....OOPS, BEST! Challenges and accomplishments Neera and Vijit’s experience proved to be...
CASE STUDY REWARD ENCOURAGES BEAST.....OOPS, BEST! Challenges and accomplishments Neera and Vijit’s experience proved to be an asset in the project. Both were technically qualified and committed to the work. Both wanted to excel in their work. Neera knew that with a big team, verbal instructions will get diluted and therefore written instructions were important. Manuals were prepared for each aspect of assessment and the entire field staff was meticulously trained so that clarity about the work and mechanism to...
QUESTION 1 1. Brianna is trying to increase her chances of being promoted to vice president...
QUESTION 1 1. Brianna is trying to increase her chances of being promoted to vice president by working to build good work relationships with other managers outside her own department. Brianna's behavior should be viewed as dysfunctional politics. functional politics. coercive power. functional influence. 2 points QUESTION 2 1. The Gingerbread Factory has a separate unit that makes their chocolate crunch cookies and another unit that is completely responsible for all operations in producing their ginger snap cookies. The Gingerbread...