Question

Jorge hired Lucy Winn to play the piano at his daughter’s wedding. Lucy agreed to play for the wedding and the reception for one flat fee. Lucy did not show up for the wedding or the reception. Jorge sued Lucy for breach of contact. Using IRAC, what would be the outcome?

Answer 1

Issue: The issue, in this case, is whether Lucy breached the contract by not showing up for the wedding or the reception to play the piano.

Rule: The rule that would be used in this case is that a breach of contract occurs when one party fails to perform their end of the agreement in the contract. This is called a non-performance breach.

Analysis: By failing to perform at the wedding or reception by playing the piano, Lucy did not perform the obligations according to the contract for which she was hired by Jorge. Therefore, this is a breach of contract by Lucy.

Conclusion: Jorge would most likely win the case after suing Lucy as she breached the terms of the contract by failing to perform the terms of the contract. The damages would be compensatory damages or a remedy here.