Question

Employment Law Instructions · You must clearly identify the question you are answering in each of...

Employment Law

Instructions

· You must clearly identify the question you are answering in each of your answers.

· You will be able to answer the questions based on the course materials (the text book, the Fair Work Act 2009 and the readings provided on Moodle).

Referencing

Please write your answers with reference to the relevant case law and legislation.

· When you refer to a provision in the legislation, you must cite the provision and the legislation (eg s 418 of the Fair Work Act).

· When you refer to a decision of a court or a tribunal you must reference the case name for the decision (eg Boilermaker’s Case).

· You may use ‘in text’ or footnote referencing.

Question 11000 word limit

‘Just Loafin’ Around’ is a chain of three bakeries in Melbourne. It is a private company 100% owned by Robert Croissant, who is also the manager of one of the stores. The business employs 4 apprentices, 6 bakers and 3 part-time administrative staff doing clerical work and payroll. It also has a pool of 5 casual employees who help out reasonably regularly when others are sick or during busy periods.

One of the people who works in the Melbourne payroll department is Robert Croissant's teenage daughter.

The store that Robert Croissant manages has two apprentices and two bakers. One of the apprentices, Bob ‘Choc’ Scone, is in his third year. The other, Crusty Bun, is in his first year and has eight months of service. Throughout the year there has been tension between the two, although nothing which has warranted any formal action or even a verbal caution.

During the weekend, Robert discovered both boys had been seeing his teenage daughter. He found out that this was the reason for the tension. This made Robert very angry.

Yesterday, Robert came into the store and in a fit of rage instantly sacked both apprentices without notice. He paid out their entitlements and dismissed them immediately.

Robert is a proud and traditional man. He could not stand the thought of working with two boys who had 'been with' his daughter. He felt he had no option but to dismiss them - besides, he thinks that there shouldn't be any of ‘that stuff’ in the workplace. While he doesn't have a formal sexual harassment policy, it is his opinion that fraternizing between staff is always a bad thing.

Robert has heard that Crusty may challenge his dismissal. The last thing he could afford is a big payout for unfair dismissal, especially since he will need two more apprentices to replace the ones he has lost. Despite this, having any of the employees back in the workplace would be equally as bad, in Robert’s opinion.

Mr Croissant wants to know:

1. Do the unfair dismissal rules apply to his firm? He heard something about small businesses being exempt, but does this apply?

2. Is he liable for the unfair dismissal and what would be his liability if Crusty’s application were successful?

3. What approach should he take if he wants to settle with Crusty?

Question 2 – Maximum 800 words

Thecommon law in determining who is an employee still places considerableemphasis on the concept of control.” Analyse and discuss.

Question 3 – Maximum 1000 words

Elizabeth and her fellow employees are employed by Ginninderra Apples Pty Ltd.Ginninderra Apples Pty Ltd is a constitutional corporation. The employees (including Elizabeth) are currently covered by a modern award.

In March 2012, Ginninderra Apples Pty Ltd approaches the employees including Elizabeth and it is proposed by them that the employees and Ginninderra Apples Pty Ltd enter into an enterprise agreement.

Ginninderra Apples Pty Ltd does not provide all employees with a notice of the employee’s representation rights prior to commencing negotiating a proposed enterprise agreement.

Ginninderra Apples Pty Ltd proposes to the employees that the agreement will reflect their current terms of employment with the exception of:

.(a) The agreement will provide for a 12% salary increase made up of four increases of 3% from 1 July in each year of the agreements operation;

.(b) The agreement will increase the weekly number of hours from 38 hours to 41 hours per week (the modern award provides for a 38 hour week);

.(c) Reduces the casual loading from 25% to 20%;

.(d) The agreement will provide the employees with 3 weeks’ annual leave;

.(e) The agreement will provide for 8 days sick leave per year which may accumulate for 3 years;

.(f) The agreement will provide for 2 days’ paid compassionate leave;

.(g) The agreement will provide for a 30 minute unpaid meal break each day;

.(h) The agreement will provide that employees will be paid monthly in arrears; and

.(i) The agreement will have a term, which will expire on 30 September 2016.

Elizabeth is concerned about the contents (terms) of the proposed agreement and seeks your advice.

Elizabeth is concerned that if she does not support the agreement, Ginninderra Apples Pty Ltd may terminate her employment.

Elizabeth is also concerned because she has sought the assistance of her union in the negotiations, but has been told by Ginninderra Apples Pty Ltd that she cannot involve them in the negotiating of the proposed agreement.

Elizabeth is also concerned about whether she will continue to enjoy the conditions in her modern award if the enterprise agreement was made and approved by Fair Work Australia.

Advise Elizabeth.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Question1

1.The unfair dismissal rule does not apply to his firm since the number of employees exceed the maximum of 15 employee all together.

Section 23 of fair work act 2009 states that employers having employees fewer than 15 employee is considered as small business. Also section 23(2) of fair act 2009 states that for calculation of number of employees all employees at that time will be considered as employee. Casual employees can be considered as employees if they are working on regular basis.

2. Yes, he can be held liable for unfair dismissal as he did not give notice and terminated the employment of crusty. Besides, there is no sexual harassment policy in that workplace makes it more difficult to defend Roberts’ action.The liability would include paying of compensation and other benefits that court may award.

3.If he wants to settle with crusty he should go for mediation process or give him the compensation.

Question 2:

The control test under common law is to determine the employee and employer relationship.

However it is very subjective. The test is to find whether the employer has the control while the employee does any act in due course of his employment.

Generally, employee follow employer as to what, how and when a thing has to be done. Certain situation where some kind of employee would work without even receiving instructions are when they are smart, qualified and trusted, however it does not mean that the employer cannot have the right to control and instruct.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Ronny is your client and has come to you to prepare his tax return. During the...
Ronny is your client and has come to you to prepare his tax return. During the 2018-19 financial year, Ronny has disposed of the following assets: Ronny purchased a motor vehicle for personal use in May 2017 from an auction warehouse for $25,000. Ronny has spent $5,000 on improvements to the vehicle. In June 2019 Ronny sells the vehicle for $45,000. Ronny purchased a vacant block of land in May 1991 for $300,000. In April 1998 Ronny subdivides the vacant...
If you were the MA taking a message in each of the following examples, identify two...
If you were the MA taking a message in each of the following examples, identify two questions you would ask the patient to complete the message. 1.) Maria Burget, is calling because she wants to know the results of blood test that were done for her daughter Isabella (DOB 7/23/2010) the previous week. Isabella is a patient of Dr. Martin. Mrs. Burget tells you that she is at work, and the best time to call is after 2:00 P.M. 2.)...
Read the case study. Identify three (3) problems and recommendations to solve the problems. Each problem...
Read the case study. Identify three (3) problems and recommendations to solve the problems. Each problem will require a justified recommended solution at least a page each. Zappos CEO Asks Employees to Commit to Teal, or Leave Zappos had modest beginnings. In 1999, shoesite.com was started by Nick Swinmurn to capture online shoe sales. Swinmurn reached out to Tony Hsieh (pronounced “shay”) and Alfred Lin, who were running Venture Frogs, a kind of venture capital group, for advice and funding....
Question -Organizational change goes beyond promotions and the threat of layoffs. What ways other than those...
Question -Organizational change goes beyond promotions and the threat of layoffs. What ways other than those discussed in the case would you use to entice people to embrace proposed changes? Provide several suggestions and justify their rationale. CASE STUDY- Blue Cross and Blue Shield, and Others: Understanding the Science behind Change Kevin Sparks has been trying to get his staff to change the way it monitors and supports the data center for the past year, but he hasn’t been getting...
CASE #1: COCA COLA The Coca-Cola company started 110 years ago as a small, insignificant one...
CASE #1: COCA COLA The Coca-Cola company started 110 years ago as a small, insignificant one man business. Since then, it has grown into one of the largest companies in the world. The first chairman of the company was Dr. John Pemberton and the current chairman is Muhtar Kent. The demand for this product has made this company into a 50 billion dollar business. Coca-Cola was invented by Dr. John Pemberton, an Atlanta pharmacist. He concocted the formula in a...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics Enron finds itself in this case. How would you describe the ethical culture and levels of trust at Enron? Provide reasons for your assessment. THE FALL OF ENRON: A STAKEHOLDER FAILURE Once upon a time, there was a gleaming headquarters office tower in Houston, with a giant tilted "£"' in front, slowly revolving in the Texas sun. The Enron Corporation, which once ranked among...
What role could the governance of ethics have played if it had been in existence in...
What role could the governance of ethics have played if it had been in existence in the organization? Assess the leadership of Enron from an ethical perspective. THE FALL OF ENRON: A STAKEHOLDER FAILURE Once upon a time, there was a gleaming headquarters office tower in Houston, with a giant tilted "£"' in front, slowly revolving in the Texas sun. The Enron Corporation, which once ranked among the top Fortune 500 companies, collapsed in 2001 under a mountain of debt...
What tools could AA leaders have used to increase their awareness of internal and external issues?...
What tools could AA leaders have used to increase their awareness of internal and external issues? ???ALASKA AIRLINES: NAVIGATING CHANGE In the autumn of 2007, Alaska Airlines executives adjourned at the end of a long and stressful day in the midst of a multi-day strategic planning session. Most headed outside to relax, unwind and enjoy a bonfire on the shore of Semiahmoo Spit, outside the meeting venue in Blaine, a seaport town in northwest Washington state. Meanwhile, several members of...
      MK Restaurant: Branding of Thai-Style Hotpot The restaurant industry is one of the most...
      MK Restaurant: Branding of Thai-Style Hotpot The restaurant industry is one of the most competitive in Thailand. With a large number of players ranging from restaurants in five-star hotels, global fast-food chains to small stalls along the streets and everything in between, the Thais are spoiled for choice. In addition, as the world becomes globalized, consumers are familiar with international dishes and would not hesitate to try new offerings from the other side of the globe. As a...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT