Question

Safiya was a learner driver. She was taking lessons from a licensed trainer Munira & Company...

Safiya was a learner driver. She was taking lessons from a licensed trainer Munira & Company Trainers. Munira the trainer accompanying Safiya checked and confirmed that Safiya’s insurance covered her for passengers before agreeing to start to her first training session. During one of the lessons Safiya lost control while trying to take a turn. Munira told her to straighten the wheel but Safiya panicked and failed to do as asked. She approached the pavement and Munira grabbed the handbrake and tried to straighten the wheel, but it was too late. She mounted the pavement and hit a lamp post. Munira sustained injuries which included a fracture in her right leg and Scrapes and Cuts some serious and some minor. She also broke her GUCCI eyeglasses and lost her Rolex make wristwatch. Munira was hospitalized for 10 days. When she returned from the hospital, she realized that 10 of her trainees had left and joined her competitor. Munira was planning to add two more cars to her fleet as she had submitted her bid for a government training contract. Munira had to delay her decision. Apart from Munira there were 65 other bidders.

Based on the sequence of events described in the above scenario, answer the following questions:

1. By using relevant law to support your answer explain whether Munira can sue Safiya? Assuming that, Munira has a valid claim against Safiya advise her on the determination of her damages. You may use relevant case law to support your answer (1mark + 4 marks = 5 Marks)

2. Explains the elements of negligence Munira will have to prove while making a claim against Safiya (You may use relevant case law to support your answer. 5

3.Explain the defenses available to Safiya if she decides to defend herself against Munira’s claim. You may use relevant case law to support your answer.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

1. Yes, Munira can sue Safia as the later is a learner driver and the accident happened due to breach of care on the part of Safia. According to law from a case of (Nettleship v Weston 1971), the court has stated that a learner driver has the same duty as that of a professional driver and any accident caused by the learner driver will be a breach of duty of care. The  duty of care of a professional driver is a legal duty of being careful and avoid accidents and also to pay damages to the victims if any accident occurs due to their breach of duty of care. In this case, Safia has breached the duty of care and should pay Munira compensation, but she also is not eligible for full compensation as Munira was also at the wheel and her timely action could have averted the accident from happening. Under the same law, this case will be a case of contributory negligence also as both Safia and Maunira were responsible for the accident as both were at the wheel. So, Munira will be eligible to get only 50% of the compensation.

Assuming that, Munira has a valid claim against Safiya for determination of damages, Munira can claim general damage due to a fracture in her right leg and some scrapes and Cut. Nominal damages can be claimed as she also broke her GUCCI eyeglasses and lost her Rolex make wristwatch. Special damages can be claimed as she was hospitalized for 10 days and that led to the loss of her clients and income.

2. The elements of negligence Munira will have to prove while making a claim against Safiya are

Responsibility- As Safiya was driving the car, there was her responsibility to be careful while driving at the wheel and should not have gotten nervous while driving. She should have been alert and cautious at the turns.

2. Breach in performing responsibility- Safia has not performed her duty of taking care while driving and due to her nervousness, she caused the accident.

3. Cause of accident- The whole accident occurred due to the fact that Safia lost control over the wheels and became nervous and rode on pavement to hit the lamp post.

4. Damages- There were huge damages suffered by Munira due to this accident.She has to prove it as it is discussed above about the nature of the accident.

3. The defenses available to Safiya if she decides to defend herself against Munira’s claim is that of volenti non fit injuria, which means that Munira has knowingly sit into the car, that she was a learner driver and may cause an accident. This is deliberately done on the part of Munira. She knowingly sits beside her and put herself in a dangerous situation deliberately.So, Safia can defend herself by stating that Munira knew of the danger and she cannot be bring any claim against her for damages. This case also refers to the above law of 1971 car accident case of Weston.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Question 1: Sukriti after graduation from MIT Sydney has been working as an accountant at Best...
Question 1: Sukriti after graduation from MIT Sydney has been working as an accountant at Best Accountants since July 2015. She married Rajib in August 2016 who at that time had been working as the Chief Financial Officer at Sydney Finance Miracle. On their first wedding anniversary, Rajib promised to buy a diamond necklace for Sukriti. However, Rajib lost his job immediately before the anniversary and as a result could not carry out his promise to Sukriti. Since then their...
Mary Barnes was employed by the Manwell Company of Maine, Wyoming [324 full-time employees].   She worked...
Mary Barnes was employed by the Manwell Company of Maine, Wyoming [324 full-time employees].   She worked at an off-site location near Maine keeping track of the inventory in that facility. Mary was the only female in the building and Milton, her supervisor, subjected her to occasional verbal abuse. [Milton had never received training concerning sexual harassment in his eight years with the company.] He often used vulgar language to refer to women, regularly told lewd jokes and made gestures insulting...
Employment Law Instructions · You must clearly identify the question you are answering in each of...
Employment Law Instructions · You must clearly identify the question you are answering in each of your answers. · You will be able to answer the questions based on the course materials (the text book, the Fair Work Act 2009 and the readings provided on Moodle). Referencing Please write your answers with reference to the relevant case law and legislation. · When you refer to a provision in the legislation, you must cite the provision and the legislation (eg s...
What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from reading their paper? How does...
What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from reading their paper? How does the topic relate to you and your current or past job? Critique the paper in terms of the organization and quality. Team 3 answer questions above. Part I In today’s world we see fear among people when dealing with sexual harassment. This leads to people not reporting sexual harassment. A misconception about sexual harassment is that it’s only about touching and forcing other people...
Please read the article below, and answer the questions that follow. In doing so, remember the...
Please read the article below, and answer the questions that follow. In doing so, remember the following, - Although the use of generic theories, covered in class/your module guide/text book will provide a framework, the expectation for the student is to be able to discuss it in context with research relevant to South Africa and your own reflective experiences. - You are required to extensively research current South African trends, amidst our changing political landscape and benchmarked against a global...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics Enron finds itself in this case. How would you describe the ethical culture and levels of trust at Enron? Provide reasons for your assessment. THE FALL OF ENRON: A STAKEHOLDER FAILURE Once upon a time, there was a gleaming headquarters office tower in Houston, with a giant tilted "£"' in front, slowly revolving in the Texas sun. The Enron Corporation, which once ranked among...
What role could the governance of ethics have played if it had been in existence in...
What role could the governance of ethics have played if it had been in existence in the organization? Assess the leadership of Enron from an ethical perspective. THE FALL OF ENRON: A STAKEHOLDER FAILURE Once upon a time, there was a gleaming headquarters office tower in Houston, with a giant tilted "£"' in front, slowly revolving in the Texas sun. The Enron Corporation, which once ranked among the top Fortune 500 companies, collapsed in 2001 under a mountain of debt...
QUESTION 1 1. Brianna is trying to increase her chances of being promoted to vice president...
QUESTION 1 1. Brianna is trying to increase her chances of being promoted to vice president by working to build good work relationships with other managers outside her own department. Brianna's behavior should be viewed as dysfunctional politics. functional politics. coercive power. functional influence. 2 points QUESTION 2 1. The Gingerbread Factory has a separate unit that makes their chocolate crunch cookies and another unit that is completely responsible for all operations in producing their ginger snap cookies. The Gingerbread...
Sign In INNOVATION Deep Change: How Operational Innovation Can Transform Your Company by Michael Hammer From...
Sign In INNOVATION Deep Change: How Operational Innovation Can Transform Your Company by Michael Hammer From the April 2004 Issue Save Share 8.95 In 1991, Progressive Insurance, an automobile insurer based in Mayfield Village, Ohio, had approximately $1.3 billion in sales. By 2002, that figure had grown to $9.5 billion. What fashionable strategies did Progressive employ to achieve sevenfold growth in just over a decade? Was it positioned in a high-growth industry? Hardly. Auto insurance is a mature, 100-year-old industry...
Actually a HISTORY question: what tactics does Einhard use to portray Charlemagne in "Life of Charlemagne"...
Actually a HISTORY question: what tactics does Einhard use to portray Charlemagne in "Life of Charlemagne" and what tactics does Procipius use to describe Justinian in a positive light in the "Nika Riots"? Ive posted both excerpts. "Life of Charlemagne" Charles the Great, (Charlemagne in French) reigned 768-814 as king of the Franks and the most important ruler of the Carolingian Dynasty, conquering lands in what is now Germany, France, Spain, and Italy. On Christmas Day 800 C.E., Pope Leo...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT