Question

"You realize," Dr. Thorne said, "that you may not be in the group that receives medication....

"You realize," Dr. Thorne said, "that you may not be in the group that receives medication. You may be in the placebo group for at least part of the time."

"Right," Ms. Ross said. "You’re just going to give me some medicine."

"And do you understand the aims of the research?"

"You wan tot help me get better," Ms. Ross suggested hesitantly.

"We hope you get better, of course. But that’s not what we’re trying to accomplish here. We’re trying to find out if this medication will help other people in your condition if we can treat them earlier than we were able to treat you."

"You want to help people," Ms. Ross said.

"That’s right. But you do understand that we may not be helping you in this experiment?"

"Not exactly. I mean, we aren’t going to try to harm you. But we aren’t necessarily going to be giving you the preferred treatment for your complaint either. Do you know the difference between research and therapy?"

"Research is when you’re trying to find something out. You’re searching around."

"That’s right. And we’re asking you to be part of a research effort. As I told you, there are some risks. Besides the possibility of not getting treatment that you need, the drug may produce limited hepatic portal damage. We’re not sure how much."

"I think I understand," Ms. Ross said.

"I’m sure you do,: said Dr. Thorne. "I understand that you are freely volunteering to participate in this research."

"Yes, sir. Mrs. Woolend, she told me if I volunteered I’d get a letter put in my file and I could get early release."

"Mrs. Woolend told you that the review board would take your volunteering into account when they consider whether you should be put on work-release."

"Yes, sir. And I’m awfully anxious to get out of here. I’ve got two children stay with my aunt, and I need to get out of this place as quick as I can."

"I understand. We can’t promise you release, of course. But your participation will look good on your record. Now I have some papers here I want you to sign."

Critical Thinking

1. State what the ethical problems are in this case. There are several. State at least three of them.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

The ethical problems faced in this case are

  1. The subject or the participant "right to withdraw " is not accepted ,respected or responded in the right way .The subject wants to leave the research where the Dr. insists that she is a volunteer and needs to be a part of the research besides her refusal to continue
  2. The subject's right to take decision is not valued here because Ms.Ross took a decision under principle of autonomy but the scenario describes that she is simply neglected
  3. The principle of of non maleficence is not followed here. This is because the mentality ,emotions and feelings of the participant has to be considered which can greatly impact the research outcome. Here the participant was in an emotional status to care for her children.
Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Read the case and answer the following Multiple choice questions. There are 5 questions total, where...
Read the case and answer the following Multiple choice questions. There are 5 questions total, where some of them might have more than one correct answers. You can choose more than one options where you think is suitable for the above question. PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT Project Manager Oliver Caine skimmed his notes as he waited for Ben Robins to come to the meeting room. He hoped Ben would arrive soon, as he wanted to get the con-versation finished quickly. Ben walked...
Katie Burns was recently hired as a cost analyst by WellCare Medical Supplies, Inc. One of...
Katie Burns was recently hired as a cost analyst by WellCare Medical Supplies, Inc. One of Katie’s first assignments was to perform a net present value analysis for a new warehouse. Katie performed the analysis and calculated a present value index of 0.75. The plant manager, Samuel McHenry, is very intent on purchasing the warehouse because he believes that more storage space is needed. Samuel asks Katie into his office and the following conversation takes place: Samuel: Katie, you’re new...
Ron Davis, the relatively new general manager of the machine tooling group at Parker Manufacturing, was...
Ron Davis, the relatively new general manager of the machine tooling group at Parker Manufacturing, was visiting one of the plants. He scheduled a meeting with Mike Leonard, a plant manager who reported to him. RON: Mike, I’ve scheduled this meeting with you because I’ve been reviewing performance data, and I wanted to give you some feedback. I know we haven’t talked face-to-face before, but I think it’s time we review how you’re doing. I’m afraid that some of the...
Kirby walked into Nancy’s office and said, “I need to talk to you.” He then closed...
Kirby walked into Nancy’s office and said, “I need to talk to you.” He then closed the door and said, “I didn’t appreciate it when you challenged my new production scheduling plan in the meeting. If you had real concerns, why didn’t you wait to talk to me in private? It’s embarrassing to have someone trash my ideas and I don’t want it to happen again.” Nancy, taken by surprise by Kirby’s response replied, “Well, I’m sorry if I embarrassed...
Brian Durkee/ Director of Operations, Numi Organic Tea: Well Numi; Numi’s is a triple bottom line...
Brian Durkee/ Director of Operations, Numi Organic Tea: Well Numi; Numi’s is a triple bottom line company which means our focuses are on people, planet and profit. Hi, I’m Brian Durkee. I’m the director of operations for Numi Organic Tea and a big part of my role at Numi is to really manage that, and uh; it’s beyond just taking care of your employees. Numi has fifty employees in the U.S. but the peoples who dedicate the majority of their...
Speaking Up in Meetings Barbara J. Krumsiek of the Calvert Group recently talked about the style...
Speaking Up in Meetings Barbara J. Krumsiek of the Calvert Group recently talked about the style of meetings that take place in her organization: I think it can be a little jarring actually for people who are used to perhaps a little more civility. I think we’re civil, but we’re direct. I don’t like meetings if my direct reports leave the room and turn to somebody and say, “Can you believe someone said that?” And so I try to explain...
Scenario Marcy recently started her first job after graduating from business school with her accounting degree....
Scenario Marcy recently started her first job after graduating from business school with her accounting degree. She is very excited to be working in her field and although she knows she still has a lot to learn, she already feels like she is getting a good feel for what it takes to be successful. She has been assigned to work under one of the senior accountants, Mrs. Bradlee, and so far, she has been easy to work with and very...
Scenario 7 ?My husband and I have talked over the matter in great detail,? Marge Gower...
Scenario 7 ?My husband and I have talked over the matter in great detail,? Marge Gower said. ?We don?t care about the sex of the child, but we know exactly the kinds of features we want.? ?Mrs. Gower,? Dr. Louise Singh said, ?you?ve got to understand that we?re not running a mail-order-catalog business for babies.? ?I?m not trying to order a baby. I just want to tell you what I?m looking for in a sperm donor. I want somebody who...
Practicing “I” language. Reflect on a few situations you’ve had recently where you may have intentionally...
Practicing “I” language. Reflect on a few situations you’ve had recently where you may have intentionally (or unintentionally) used a “you” statement to someone important in your life. For example: “You’re always so self-centered!” “You never let me finish when we talk!” “You’re always so rude to me!” Likely, you made these statements out of frustration with a particular behavior. Unfortunately, “you” statements tend to promote defensiveness in the long run and typically only solve the problematic behavior in question...
Geoff Cranch, a psychiatric mental health nurse, walks into a conference room where Sylvie Waters, a...
Geoff Cranch, a psychiatric mental health nurse, walks into a conference room where Sylvie Waters, a patient who has been exhibiting signs of extreme depression, waits in a folding chair in front of a desk. “Hi, Mrs. Waters,” he says. “Sorry to hear you’re not feeling well. I just want to ask you a few questions and kind of see where we’re at with things.” He takes a seat behind a desk and boots up the computer. “Sorry, this is...