Question

Case Study One of the fears of opponents regarding a “right to die” is that in...

Case Study

One of the fears of opponents regarding a “right to die” is that in the future the courts will extend the “right” to other vulnerable populations. Under the Oregon legislation, the patient is prescribed a lethal medication but in the end must take it himself. This then is a form of physi- cian-assisted suicide. Could it be argued that the incapacitated patient who could not take the medication without assistance has an equal right? Would this then expand the right not only to physician-assisted suicide but to physician active euthanasia? In the Vacco v. Quill case, it was argued that if a right to die could be found under the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution, then a law that allowed a patient who wanted to be disconnected from artificial life support to do so, but barred others who wanted to take lethal drugs to similarly hasten their death, would violate the amendment’s equal protection guarantee because it treated the two groups differently.

a. Are the two groups—patients refusing care and an individual wishing a lethal prescription—the same?

b. The U.S. Supreme Court did not find a right to die under the Constitution. Do you think this was the right decision?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

a. Are the two groups—patients refusing care and an individual wishing a lethal prescription—the same? - No, The patient's refusing the life-support during the end of life stage is different from taking the lethal prescription that invites death, both must considered differently.

b. The U.S. Supreme Court did not find a right to die under the Constitution. Do you think this was the right decision? Yes, because not including the "Right to die" in the constitution remains the chances of survival open for all the individuals in any situation in their lives and protect the "Right to life."

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
In two or more sentences ( in your OWN words) what response would you give the...
In two or more sentences ( in your OWN words) what response would you give the statement below? I need a response for the statement . Any correction or add to the statements? Euthanasia is an act carried out by a doctor that ends a patient’s life, in which the patient is suffering from extreme pain or when life unstainable. Euthanasia is different from physician-assisted suicide because the doctor carries out the final act that causes death. Physician-assisted suicide when...
write 3-5 sentences response to this post in your own words . I believe that active...
write 3-5 sentences response to this post in your own words . I believe that active voluntary euthanasia is morally permissible as long as it is, in fact, voluntary (I also find active nonvoluntary euthanasia permissible as long as a trusted decision-maker is present). In some cases, I would actually prefer it to passive euthanasia because it would be quicker and (as far as we know) not painful for the patient. In the case of brain death or in other...
Case study On April 5, 1984, William Bartling was admitted to the Glendale Adventist Medical Center...
Case study On April 5, 1984, William Bartling was admitted to the Glendale Adventist Medical Center in Los Angeles. He was seventy years old and suffered from five ordinarily fatal diseases: emphysema, diffuse arteriosclerosis, coronary arteriosclerosis, an abdominal aneurysm, and inoperable lung cancer. During the performance of a biopsy to diagnose the lung cancer, Mr. Bartling's left lung collapsed. He was placed in the ICU, and a chest tube and mechanical respirator were used to assist his breathing. Mr. Bartling...
READ AND FIX GRAMMER Facts a. This case is patient to the physician about the right...
READ AND FIX GRAMMER Facts a. This case is patient to the physician about the right to die. The nature of the case is a thirty-two-year-old Nancy Cruz who was in a persistent vegetative state since 1983 could not order the physician to remove artificial nutrition. In 1983 she was in a car accident, and she was found face down in a dish without respiratory or cardiac function. She was unconscious on the accident and paramedics were able to restore...
QUESTION 1 (60) Read the case study below and answer the questions that follow. Transforming a...
QUESTION 1 (60) Read the case study below and answer the questions that follow. Transforming a pharmacy together: the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic hospital. Before 2015, the patient experience at the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital pharmacy went something like this: take the day off work to have your prescription filled; line up at dawn before the pharmacy opens in hopes of beating the rush; once inside, wait up to several hours for your prescription to be filled; or worse,...
Janet Broom and Darla Miller were employed as certified medication aide and cook, respectively, at the...
Janet Broom and Darla Miller were employed as certified medication aide and cook, respectively, at the employer's residential care facility located in Norman, Oklahoma. Both employees suspected another employee of stealing and using drugs, intended for use by residents of the faculty, from the facility’s medication room. Broom and Miller decided to report the suspected employee based on their observation that she had falsified medical drug log books to conceal her theft from facility managers. The facility’s Employee Handbook clearly...
read Seasons of Love chapter:measuring a child's life after suicide. please answer the questions : reflect...
read Seasons of Love chapter:measuring a child's life after suicide. please answer the questions : reflect on what happens to the families when there is a suicide in the family, based on the Seasons of Love chapter...how should people be told? What details are best left unshared? below is the story These theories may have a certain face-validity, but they often neglect environmental or contextual factors that are innate to answering the question of “why” a person might engage in...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics...
Discuss ethical issues that can be identified in this case and the mode of managing ethics Enron finds itself in this case. How would you describe the ethical culture and levels of trust at Enron? Provide reasons for your assessment. THE FALL OF ENRON: A STAKEHOLDER FAILURE Once upon a time, there was a gleaming headquarters office tower in Houston, with a giant tilted "£"' in front, slowly revolving in the Texas sun. The Enron Corporation, which once ranked among...
Actually a HISTORY question: what tactics does Einhard use to portray Charlemagne in "Life of Charlemagne"...
Actually a HISTORY question: what tactics does Einhard use to portray Charlemagne in "Life of Charlemagne" and what tactics does Procipius use to describe Justinian in a positive light in the "Nika Riots"? Ive posted both excerpts. "Life of Charlemagne" Charles the Great, (Charlemagne in French) reigned 768-814 as king of the Franks and the most important ruler of the Carolingian Dynasty, conquering lands in what is now Germany, France, Spain, and Italy. On Christmas Day 800 C.E., Pope Leo...