Question

How would someone respond to this situation using the ethical principles of: (Respond using the principles...

How would someone respond to this situation using the ethical principles of: (Respond using the principles of RAWLSIAN? Scenario #1 "This gentleman is Ethan Zinker," Dr. Clara Woods said. She bent over the bed and put her stethoscope to the chest of the elderly man. He stirred but showed no sign of waking. "He's got pneumonia," Dr. Woods said, straightening up. "But aside for being ninety-two years old, and having lost a few of his marbles, nothing else is wrong with him. If we treated him aggressively with antibiotics, he might live for another six or eight years. Maybe more." She shrugged. "But we're only controlling his fever and keeping him comfortable." "How come you're not giving him antibiotics?" Dr. Robert Elias was shocked. He was Morningside Hospital's new bioethicist and it was his first morning of making rounds with Dr. Woods. "I mean, he has a life-threatening disease that usually responds well to therapy." "Right," Dr. Woods said, nodding. "But he's also got an advanced directive that tells us in no uncertain terms not to intervene." She flipped through the chart until she located the social worker's report. "He was the Powell professor of physics at Columbia. A very smart guy, he couldn't stand the idea of not being mentally sharp and active." "So he said if he began to fail mentally, then if he needed treatment to keep him alive, he didn't want to have it." Dr.Elias was beginning to understand. "Exactly," Dr. Woods said. "But the funny thing is, when he started to get senile and moved into the nursing home, he quite liked it." She smiled. "He couldn't recognize his daughter most of the time, but he knows the people he lives with and sees everyday. He's made a couple of friends, and according to these notes, he like watching reruns of X-Files." "He should be treated," Dr. Elias said flatly. "The idea of not treating someone who is evidently enjoying life struck him as very wrong." "I think so, too," Dr. Woods said. "The only right course of action is to ignore the advance directive and treat him. Let's face it, Professor Zinker didn't know what his life would be like now when he gave his directive. It wouldn't be a good life for him the way he used to be, but that's not the way he is now." His expression turned grim. "He needs to be treated, before it's too late to help him." ***************************************************************************** Ethan Zinker is a 92 year old former professor who filled out an advanced directive indicating that he wanted no further medical treatments if he began to fail mentally. He had done so, becoming senile, but had also indicated that he liked the nursing home and his life there. He now has pneumonia. Should he be given anti-biotics and be kept alive or not? Should his advanced directive be respected or ignored? How would someone respond to this situation using the ethical principles of: (Respond using the principles of RAWLSIAN?  

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Answer. Rawlsian law considers the concept of overlapping the generalised approach of advanced directive above the rigid theoretical approach to it. It means that it can be sidelined, if the conditions or the situations are favorable.

According to this law, the advance directive of former professor Ethan Zinker can be overseen and the treatment of antibiotics can be started to ensure his big life span, because his body can accept the high doses of antibiotics thereby treating his illness and curing him to a healthy life. The rule or law of giving opportunity to someone to live will help in making the decision to skip the advance directive and continue the treatment.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles of: (Respond using the principles...
How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles of: (Respond using the principles of the ethical Kantian scenario # 1 ?You?ve got to help us,? Clarence Woody said. ?Keith is ? was ? our only child, and he meant the world to us. When the police came and told us he was dead, all Sara and I could think of was how we could get him back.? ?But you can?t get him back,? Dr. Alma Lieu said....
How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles using a rule utilitarian Scenario...
How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles using a rule utilitarian Scenario #5 Consider the following five cases. Harvey Shick of Tyler, Texas, on June 1, 1983, shot his wife in the head twice with a .22-caliber pistol. Marie Shick had suffered from severe arteriosclerosis since the late 1970s and suffered extreme pain in her lower legs. The couple had been happily married for forty-five years. Although Mr. Shick was charged with murder, the charges were...
How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles of a natural law theorist...
How would someone respond to this question using the ethical principles of a natural law theorist Scenario #6 In 1993 the Netherlands passed a law permitting physicians to assist in the suicide of terminally ill patients. The law requires that the patient's decision to die be informed and irrevocable, and that there be no other solution acceptable to the patient that would improve the situation. In the USA the state of Oregon has a law allowing physicians to prescribe medication...
Scenario #6 Dr. Daniel McKay and his wife, Carol, had only a few moment of joy...
Scenario #6 Dr. Daniel McKay and his wife, Carol, had only a few moment of joy at the birth of his son. They learned almost immediately that their child was severely impaired. Half an hour later, the infant was dead-Dr. McKay, a veterinarian, had slammed him onto the floor of the delivery room. Mrs. McKay had had problems during pregnancy. An ultrasound test indicated excessive fluid in the uterus, a sign that something might be wrong. Dr. Joaquin Ramos assured...
Shamus’s family come to talk to you about their his care. They want to speak to...
Shamus’s family come to talk to you about their his care. They want to speak to you because they trust you as someone who has worked very closely with Shamus as a palliative care worker for the last two months. They are very distressed about a report they have received from the doctor, who has told them that Shamus has only days to live. His family ask you to refer them to a different doctor – there must be something...
Decision Scenario #7 Helen and John Kent waited nervously in the small consulting room while Laurie...
Decision Scenario #7 Helen and John Kent waited nervously in the small consulting room while Laurie Stent, their genetic counselor, went to tell Dr. Carles Blatz that they had arrived to talk to him. ?I regret that I have some bad new for you,? Dr. Blatz told them. ?the karyotyping that we do after aminocentesis shows a chromosomal abnormality.? He looked at them, and Helen felt she could hardly breathe. ?What is it?? she asked. ?It?s a condition known as...
The Harborside Inn, located on the New England coast, is a 125-room luxury hotel. The inn's...
The Harborside Inn, located on the New England coast, is a 125-room luxury hotel. The inn's guests are predominantly upper middle class in that the going rate is about $100 per day per person. The hotel grounds include 30 acres of lawns and gardens. Their nine-hole golf course winds its way around a picturesque trout pond. The hotel grounds were meticulously cared for and yet efforts at cultivating beauty could not match the natural beauty which was so much a...
It had been a busy day for Marsha Chamberland. She had spent most of it cleaning...
It had been a busy day for Marsha Chamberland. She had spent most of it cleaning and running errands in prepara- tion for her brother-in-law Ed’s return, and now she was preparing a quick dinner for her family. Ed, an industry official whose job it was to decide whether or not new products needed premarket approval by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, had spent the last two weeks in Tennessee expressing his views on genetic engineering in food. He...
In narrative essay format, I want you to address a business/organization case study using multiple concepts...
In narrative essay format, I want you to address a business/organization case study using multiple concepts from class. The case question and case text begin on page 5 of this document. You need to demonstrate their best understanding of management and organizational behavior theory, and the application of those ideas to improve the understanding of various issues. You need to clearly identify at least 3 distinct, substantive issues. For each issue you need to 1), identify evidence from the case...
PLEASE READ THE ARTICLES ATTACHED AND ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTION. THE ARTICLES ARE BOTH LISTED PLEASE...
PLEASE READ THE ARTICLES ATTACHED AND ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTION. THE ARTICLES ARE BOTH LISTED PLEASE PROVIDE DETAILED EXPLANATIONS. PLEASE WRITE ONE REFLECTION COMBINING BOTH ARTICLES. The purpose of the Article Reflection is to deepen your engagement with the topic of Epidemiology. It will give you the opportunity to reflect on the current real-life epidemiological issues at hand and help to bring meaning to them. ARTICLE 1: A group of students knew they had covid-19. They hosted a party over...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT