A steel pipe X feet long is able to withstand Y tonnes of tensile load. Can you trust this pipe to withstand a Y tonne compressive load? How do you know?
There is no surety that the given pipe can withstand Y tonnes of load in compression as well. During compression ductile material fails by buckling OR by bulging. If the length of the steel pipe is long enough, then it will fail by buckling. The Euler load required for buckling can be less than the tensile load Y depending upon the dimensions of pipe. So as the diameter and length of steel pipe is not known here then we can not say that the pipe will withstand the Y load in compression.
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.