Question

Prove that the following arguments are invalid. 1. (∃x) (Ax * ~Bx) 2. (∃x) (Ax *...

Prove that the following arguments are invalid.

1. (∃x) (Ax * ~Bx)

2. (∃x) (Ax * ~Cx)

3. (∃x) ( ~Bx * Dx)

/ (∃x) [Ax *(~Bx * Dx)]

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Answer :

1. (∃x) (Ax * ~Bx) Premise

2. (∃x) (Ax * ~Cx)   Premise

3. (∃x) ( ~Bx * Dx) Premise

4. Aa * ~Ba (1) , Existential Instantiation

5. Aa (4) , Simplification

6. ~Ba    (4) , Simplification

7. Aa * ~Ca (2) , Existential Instantiation

8. Aa (7) , Simplification

9. ~Ca (7) , Simplification

10.  ~Ba * Da (3) ,Existential Instantiation

11. Aa *(~Ba * Da) (10), Simplification

12. (∃x) [Ax *(~Bx * Dx)] (11), Existential Generalization

Thus , the conclusion  (∃x) [Ax *(~Bx * Dx)] is derived from the given premises and hence the argument is valid

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Prove that the following arguments are invalid. Use the method of interpretation to do this. Thank...
Prove that the following arguments are invalid. Use the method of interpretation to do this. Thank you. (1) 1. (∃x)(Ax ⋅ Bx) 2. (∃x)(Bx ⋅ Cx) /∴ (∃x)(Ax ⋅ Cx) (3) 1. (∃x)(Ax ⋅ ~ Bx) 2. (∃x)(Ax ⋅ ~Cx) 3. (∃x)(~ Bx ⋅ Dx) /∴ (∃x)[Ax ⋅ (~ Bx ⋅ Dx)] (5) 1. ( ∃x)(Px ⋅ ~ Qx) 2. (x)(Rx ⊃ Px) /∴ ( ∃x)(Rx ⋅ ~ Qx)
Write an assembly language program that will implement the following: If ( (AX >=BX) || (CX...
Write an assembly language program that will implement the following: If ( (AX >=BX) || (CX < DX) ) goto LoopA Else go to LoopB..
Write an assembly language program that will implement the following:       If ( (AX >=BX) AND (CX...
Write an assembly language program that will implement the following:       If ( (AX >=BX) AND (CX < DX) ) goto LoopA Else go to LoopB (Here I want you to write the whole assembly program that could run in CMD. THANK YOU
Suppose that f(x)=ax^3+bx^2+cx+d cubic polynomial.. Show that f(x) and k(x)=f(x-2) have the same number of roots.(without...
Suppose that f(x)=ax^3+bx^2+cx+d cubic polynomial.. Show that f(x) and k(x)=f(x-2) have the same number of roots.(without quadratic formula)
1) find a cubic polynomial with only one root f(x)=ax^3+bx^2+cx +d such that it had a...
1) find a cubic polynomial with only one root f(x)=ax^3+bx^2+cx +d such that it had a two cycle using Newton’s method where N(0)=2 and N(2)=0 2) the function G(x)=x^2+k for k>0 must ha e a two cycle for Newton’s method (why)? Find the two cycle
Suppose you have a function of the general form e(x) = ax^3 + bx^2 + cx...
Suppose you have a function of the general form e(x) = ax^3 + bx^2 + cx + d a, b, c, and d are real numbers. Find values for the coefficients if -there is a local maximum at (6,6) -there is a local minimum at (10,2) -there is an inflection point at (8,4) Please show how you solve and explain.
1102) a) intg{dx}=Ax+C. b) intg{x dx}=Bx^D + C. c) intg{(1/x^2)dx}=Ex^F + C. d) intg{7x^8 dx}=Gx^H +...
1102) a) intg{dx}=Ax+C. b) intg{x dx}=Bx^D + C. c) intg{(1/x^2)dx}=Ex^F + C. d) intg{7x^8 dx}=Gx^H + C. Answers: A,B,D,E,F,G,H. ans:7 1104) a) intg{4(x+8) dx}=Ax^2 + Bx + C. b) intg{(8/sqrt(2x)) dx}=Dx^E + C. Answers: A,B,D,E,F,G,H c) intg{sqrt(x)(7x-6) dx}=(Fx+G)x^H + C. ans:7
The function f(x) = x^3+ax^2+bx+7 has a relative extrema at x = 1 and x =...
The function f(x) = x^3+ax^2+bx+7 has a relative extrema at x = 1 and x = -3. a.) What are the values of a and b? b.) Use the second derivative test to classify each extremum as a relative maximum or a relative minimum. c.) Determine the relative extrema.
Find the matrix operator T: P3 --> P2 where T [= T(a + bx + cx^2...
Find the matrix operator T: P3 --> P2 where T [= T(a + bx + cx^2 + dx^3) = b + 2cx + 3dx^2 with respect to bases B = {1, x, x^2, x^3} and C = {1, x, 2x^2, -1}.
Given the components of the vectors, A, B, and C Ax = 5 Bx=4 Cx =10...
Given the components of the vectors, A, B, and C Ax = 5 Bx=4 Cx =10 Ay = -3 By=6 Cy =6 Az = 10 Bz=-2 Cz =0 Find (a) AiCiBx, (b) AiAyBi, (c) AiBiCj , and (d) AiBiCjAk