QUESTION 5 Note: Where applicable, use the present
value tables provided in APPENDICES 1 and 2 that appear after
REQUIRED Use the information given below to calculate the
following:
5.1 Payback Period of both projects (answers expressed in years and
months).
5.2 Accounting Rate of Return of Project A (answer expressed to two
decimal places).
5.3 Net Present Value (NPV) of both projects (amounts rounded off
to the nearest Rand).
5.4 Profitability Index of Project B (answer expressed to two
decimal places).
5.5 Internal Rate of Return of Project B (answer expressed to two
decimal places).
INFORMATION Gentry Ltd had to choose between these two projects,
Project A or Project B, for which the following net cash inflows
have been forecasted:
Year 1 2 3 4
Project A R60 000 R160 000 R200 000 R360 000
Project B R172 000 R172 000 R172 000 R172 000
Project A requires an investment of R560 000 while project Project
B requires an investment of R500 000. The average annual profit of
projects Project A and Project B are expected to be R55 000 and R47
000 respectively. Both projects are expected to have no salvage
value. The minimum required rate of return on these projects is
12%.
5.1 - Payback period
Project A
Capital outlay (in USD) |
560,000 |
Cash inflows table
Year |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Cash inflows (in USD) |
60,000 |
160,000 |
200,000 |
360,000 |
Cumulative cashinflows |
60,000 |
220,000 |
420,000 |
780,000 |
Step 1 : Monthly cash inflows for 4th year |
30,000.00 |
Step 2 : Additional cashflow
required - post year 3 to reap the initial cash outlay |
140,000 |
No. of months to get
cashflows of USD 140,000 in year 4 |
4.67 |
Rounding off to next month |
5 |
Therefore payback period for Project A is 3 years 5 months
Project B
Capital outlay (in USD) |
500,000 |
Cash inflows table
Year |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Cash inflows (in USD) |
172,000 |
172,000 |
172,000 |
172,000 |
Cumulative cashinflows |
172,000 |
344,000 |
516,000 |
688,000 |
Step 1 : Monthly cash inflows for 3rd year |
14,333.33 |
Step 2 : Additional cashflow
required - post year 2 to reap the initial cash outlay |
156,000 |
No. of months to get
cashflows of USD 156,000 in year 3 |
10.88 |
Rounding off to next month |
11 |
Therefore payback period for Project B is 2 years 11 months
5.2 Accounting Rate of Return of Project A
Computation of Average Investment
Details |
Project A |
Project B |
Value of investment at year 0 |
560,000.00 |
500,000.00 |
Value of investment at year 4 (no salvage value) |
- |
- |
Average Investment -- >(Investment at year 0 + Investment at Year 4)/2 |
280,000.00 |
250,000.00 |
Computation of Accounting rate of return
Details |
Project A |
Project B |
Average annual profits |
55,000.00 |
47,000.00 |
Average Investment (refer above table) |
280,000.00 |
250,000.00 |
Accounting rate of return ----> (Average annual profits / Average investment) *100 |
19.64% |
18.80% |
5.3 Net Present Value (NPV)
Project A
Cashflow table
Year |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Investment |
(560,000.00) |
||||
Annual cashflows |
60,000.00 |
160,000.00 |
200,000.00 |
360,000.00 |
|
Net cashflows |
(560,000.00) |
60,000.00 |
160,000.00 |
200,000.00 |
360,000.00 |
PV factor @ 12% |
1.0000 |
0.8929 |
0.7972 |
0.7118 |
0.6355 |
PV of cashflows |
(560,000.00) |
53,571.43 |
127,551.02 |
142,356.05 |
228,786.51 |
NPV |
(7,735) |
Project B
Cashflow table
Year |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Investment |
(500,000.00) |
||||
Annual cashflows |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
|
Net cashflows |
(500,000.00) |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
PV factor @ 12% |
1.0000 |
0.8929 |
0.7972 |
0.7118 |
0.6355 |
PV of cashflows |
(500,000.00) |
153,571.43 |
137,117.35 |
122,426.20 |
109,309.11 |
NPV |
22,424 |
5.4 Profitability Index of Project B
Year |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Annual cashflows |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
Net cashflows |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
PV factor @ 12% |
0.8929 |
0.7972 |
0.7118 |
0.6355 |
PV of cashflows |
153,571.43 |
137,117.35 |
122,426.20 |
109,309.11 |
Present value of future cashflows |
522,424 |
Present value of future cashflows |
522,424 |
Initial investment |
500,000 |
Profitability Index
---> |
1.04 |
5.5 Internal Rate of Return of Project B
NPV @ 12%
Year |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Investment |
(500,000.00) |
||||
Annual cashflows |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
|
Net cashflows |
(500,000.00) |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
172,000.00 |
PV factor @ 12% |
1.0000 |
0.8929 |
0.7972 |
0.7118 |
0.6355 |
PV of cashflows |
(500,000.00) |
153,571.43 |
137,117.35 |
122,426.20 |
109,309.11 |
NPV |
22,424 |
NPV @ 15%