Question

Critical Incident 2- Job analysis At the last meeting of managers and supervisors, a major topic...

Critical Incident 2- Job analysis

At the last meeting of managers and supervisors, a major topic of discussion pertained to employee confusion regarding their job duties. Some employees refuse to do any work outside their usual routine, exclaiming, “That’s not my job!” This is somewhat understandable since the company has no written job descriptions. Job duties have been informal understandings, originating when the company began only a few years ago (when the company had few employees), and no one had the time or inclination to rectify the situation.

As HR manager, you have investigated the various methods and costs of doing a job analysis for the company. Any job analysis program includes writing a job description for each job in the company. You have discovered that job descriptions have many uses, including: recruitment, interviewing, orientation, training, job evaluation, wage compensation survey, performance appraisal, and outplacement. Although there are no dangerous jobs in your operation, the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 requirements state that a company must specify “elements of the job that endanger health, or are to be considered unsatisfactory or distasteful to the majority of the population.” Providing a job description to employees is a good defense against possible legal actions. Since you do not have the personnel or in-house expertise to do the work, you have received bids from various companies to do the work.

Proposals below are from the best-qualified and most reasonably priced company you could locate. Make one selection from the following options; the one-time cost will automatically be charged against your budget.

1. Analyze all jobs, including managerial. (Cost: $20,000)- Option chosen

2. Analyze production/operations jobs. (Cost: $15,000)-

3. Categorize production/operations jobs, and do a job analysis for each category. (Cost: $10,000)

4. Hire a consultant to make a plan for doing job analysis in-house. (Cost: $5,000)

5. Put the project on hold. (Cost: none)

I am needing help finding the pros and cons for options 2 and 4. Options 1,3, and 5 have already been taken care of.

My question is: Why would option 2 and 4 not be good options for this assignment. Also, would there be any positive points for the options?  

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Option 2 is not good as it is costing way too much for analyzing only the production or operation jobs. Moreover option 1 already takes care of all the categories at a comparitively low cost.In comparison to option 1 and 3 option 2 is not relevant.

option 4 on the other hand just looks into the planning of the job analysis rather than actually analyzing it. The planning is already on point so as to analyse the various jobs. Option 4 will act as a additional cost as other options are already taking care of the analysis.

The advantages of option2 will be that it would look into the matter in much depth as compared to option 1. It would look into the requirement of the particular jobs and assign who is perfect for the respective job.

Option 4 wpould help in reducing the burden already prevailing in the company and may assist the manager in assigning the right person on the right job.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
You receive two job offers in the same big city. The first job is close to...
You receive two job offers in the same big city. The first job is close to your​ parents' house, and they have offered to let you live at home for a year so you​ won't have to incur expenses for​ housing, food, or cable and Internet. This job pays $45,000 per year. The second job is far away from your​ parents' house, so​ you'll have to rent an apartment with parking ​($12,500 per​ year), buy your own food ​($2,250 per​...
An employee has come to you with a request to take on a part-time job. The...
An employee has come to you with a request to take on a part-time job. The employee would be working for Price Waterhouse as a contract employee during tax season. The employee has assured you that she will not work more than 20 hours a week, primarily on weekends. Price-Waterhouse is one of the five accounting firms that has put a bid in to do the auditing for G-BioSport. Be Reasonable: Explore the Options Basic Liberties Choose three options to...
Business idea: Create a job board site that presents companies in a compelling manner, to make...
Business idea: Create a job board site that presents companies in a compelling manner, to make job listings interesting and to provide job seekers a better sense of what it would be like to work for a particular company. pitch: Job boards and company profiles on job sites are fairly uninspiring. Usually, there is a boring description of a job, followed by a list of skills and educational background needed and a dull description of the company. Rarely is any...
In May 2011, Mississippi River flooding hit Vicksburg, Mississippi, and the Optima Air Filter Company. Many...
In May 2011, Mississippi River flooding hit Vicksburg, Mississippi, and the Optima Air Filter Company. Many employees’ homes were devastated. Optima found that it had to hire almost three completely new crews, one for each shift. The problem was that the “old-timers” had known their jobs so well that no one had ever bothered to draw up job descriptions for them. When about 30 new employees began taking their places, there was general confusion about what they should do and...
Team 5 answer the questions What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from...
Team 5 answer the questions What are 4 key things you learned about the topic from reading their paper? How does the topic relate to you and your current or past job? Critique the paper in terms of the organization and quality. Incentive Systems             In this paper, we will focus primarily on financial rewards that companies use to attract, retain and motivate the brightest and most talented candidates in the labor market. By providing a reward system that...
My Homework: look at any one topic covered in the discussion boards making sure the topic...
My Homework: look at any one topic covered in the discussion boards making sure the topic generated a lot of interesting class participation. Re-read the comments of your peers and your original post: what do you think about the issue now? Has the conversation changed your view point or only strengthened it? Why? Finally, what are the things you can take away from the course overall? Are there specific concepts and ideas that were eye-opening to you personally? Do you...
Chapter 9 is about decision making. please read the comment and response and In 3-4 paragraphs....
Chapter 9 is about decision making. please read the comment and response and In 3-4 paragraphs. Please discuss your input/opinion. The focus of our discussion will be this article that I read in last week's New York Times. This is an open ended discussion with no framing question. I have gained tremendous insight reading the comments on this blog. One in particular really struck me recently. It came in response to a post that I had written quite a while...
Section A. Job Analysis Case Scenario 1: The following case scenario is the background that would...
Section A. Job Analysis Case Scenario 1: The following case scenario is the background that would guide your answers in Sections A. You are the Human Resources Manager at the Bahrain office of a well reputed real estate firm ‘Homes are Us’ specialized in creating, selling, and maintaining the high-end residential spaces. The company’s headquarters is in Bahrain, with other offices in Saudi Arabia, Oman & Kuwait and employs around 100 professionals. The sales team comprises of a Sales Manager,...
why should managers take time to understand the individual differences you selected from the perspective of...
why should managers take time to understand the individual differences you selected from the perspective of the potential impact of the individual difference on OB? Individual behavior are the approaches in which humans fluctuate from every other. Every member of a corporation has its very own way of behavior. It is essential for managers to apprehend man or woman variations due to the fact they have an impact on the feelings, thoughts, and conduct of employees. Individuals carry various variations...
CASE A: THE PLANTATION VACATION HOUSE: The New Performance Management System The Plantation Vacation House’s competitive...
CASE A: THE PLANTATION VACATION HOUSE: The New Performance Management System The Plantation Vacation House’s competitive strategy is “To use superior guest service to differentiate the PVH properties, and to thereby increase the length of stay and return rate of guests, and thus boost revenues and profitability.” HR manager Ali Hassan must now formulate functional policies and activities that support this competitive strategy, by eliciting the required employee behaviors and competencies. Ali knew that the PVH’s performance appraisal system was...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT