Question

What is the advantage of using the HDI over the GNP as an indicator of development?...

What is the advantage of using the HDI over the GNP as an indicator of development? What are the limitations of the HDI, and why is it “vulnerable to the allegation of a certain Eurocentrism”?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

The Human Development Index (HDI) is a composite statistic of life expectancy, education, and income per capita indicators, which are used to rank countries into four tiers of human development.

Advantages:

  • HDI combines 3 most important indicators of development into score between 0-1.1 indicates a high level of economic development and 0 a very low level.
  • The HDI was introduced to combine three measures – life expectancy (a social measure), education (average number of years of schooling and expected years of schooling– a social measure) and gross national income per capita (an economic measure).
  • It takes into account health, knowledge & wealth in the form of life expectancy, adult literacy & GNP.
  • HDI uses 2 types of social data (health and education) and 1 type of economic data which means that the measure uses a broad range of information and is not tied up with only one measure. This is a much more accurate measure.
  • The information is updated annually and collected by a range of people who ensure that the data is as accurate as possible.
  • Allows direct comparisons to be made between countries and is an attempt to combine an economic indicator with social indicators, giving a more rounded view of standards in different countries.
  • Doesn't rely solely on wealth, gives an indicator of quality of life by including health and education.
  • HDI includes a measure of GNI, life expectancy and education.

Disadvantages

  • It usually averages for the whole country's population, meaning they do not always reveal substantial inequalities between different segment of society.
  • Data used can be out of date data or hard to collect in some countries.
  • The HDI fails to recognize inequality that exists outside the numbers calculated.
  • Higher national wealth does not indicate welfare. GNI may not necessarily increase economic welfare; it depends on how it is spent.
  • Higher GNI per capita may hide widespread inequality within a country. Some countries with higher real GNI per capita have high levels of inequality (e.g. Russia, Saudi Arabia)

Eurocentrism refers to considering Europe is the center. The idea that Europe and the United States are the main actors in the political and economic world. The remainder of is simply a periphery or a respondent to the actions of the main actor, passive subject in world history. HDI focusses on every country in the world meeting the standards of the west. So, it is being criticized for being Eutocentric. In reality every country can't be expected to meet the standards of the west as it would be unfair.

To conclude HDI has both pros and cons. On the one hand, this index is a great way for measuring development as it is not solely based on economic growth but on the other hand it does not incorporate many dimensions that play an important role in the development of country.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
What is the principal advantage of ac over dc?
What is the principal advantage of ac over dc?
The indicator methyl red has a pKHIn=4.95. It changes from red to yellow over the pH...
The indicator methyl red has a pKHIn=4.95. It changes from red to yellow over the pH range from 4.4 to 6.2. Part A I f the indicator is placed in a buffer solution of pH = 4.60, what percent of the indicator will be present in the acid form, HIn, and what percent will be present in the base or anion form, In−? Express your answer using two significant figures. Enter your answers numerically separated by a comma.
What were the competing perspectives of economic development and how did the concept shift over time?...
What were the competing perspectives of economic development and how did the concept shift over time? make an argument as to why or why not economic development is synonymous with economic growth.
What is the biggest advantage of using outsourcing for data analytics project and why??
What is the biggest advantage of using outsourcing for data analytics project and why??
What is an advantage to using an autotransformer connection and what is a disadvantage in using...
What is an advantage to using an autotransformer connection and what is a disadvantage in using an autotransformer connection?
What is the biggest advantage of the Base-stock model over the RQ model? What is the...
What is the biggest advantage of the Base-stock model over the RQ model? What is the biggest advantage of the RQ model over the Base-stock model? List two alternative conditions under which a company would not need to carry any safety stock.
What is the major advantage of electrophoresis over other types of chromatography?
What is the major advantage of electrophoresis over other types of chromatography?
what advantage does the process of crossing over bring to reproduction?
what advantage does the process of crossing over bring to reproduction?
Identify a comparative advantage that exists between two countries globally. Justify/argue persuasively (using examples) for the...
Identify a comparative advantage that exists between two countries globally. Justify/argue persuasively (using examples) for the comparative advantage and why you think one country may have a comparative advantage over the other country.
What type of advantage, if any, is there to the "spore system" when compared to animal...
What type of advantage, if any, is there to the "spore system" when compared to animal gamete development? Can you argue that this applies to all green plants in the same way? Why or why not?