Question

Problem 4 “An import quota and a tariff have exactly the same effect on price, and...

Problem 4 “An import quota and a tariff have exactly the same effect on price, and bring the same gains and losses, provided that the import quota restricts imports just as much as the tariff.” Indicate one situation in which this statement is true, and another situation in which this statement is false.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

In a situation, when the objective is to protect the domestic industries and it is to be done by restricting the import to the country. In this case, quota and tariff serve the same purpose. In both the case, there will be loss of total welfare in the economy.

Though in a situation, when objective of the government is to earn revenues as tariff revenue, then both the policies are different. Tariff system, will bring tariff revenue to the government, but quota system will not bring the revenue. Here, government will earn revenue with loss to the welfare.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
A- What is the production effect of a tariff? How would you describe it in words,...
A- What is the production effect of a tariff? How would you describe it in words, without reference to any diagram or numbers? How would you show it on a diagram, and how would you compute its value? B- How are trade creation and trade diversion defined, and what roles do they play in the world gains and losses from a trade bloc? C- A small price-taking nation imports a good that it could not possibly produce itself at any...
True or False: The imposition of an import tariff by a large country can cause an...
True or False: The imposition of an import tariff by a large country can cause an increase in the country’s welfare. When demand increases for a good subject to a quota the price would stay the same but imports would increase. Is true or false?why? thanks
If a tariff in a small country reduces consumer surplus by $100, increases tariff revenue by...
If a tariff in a small country reduces consumer surplus by $100, increases tariff revenue by $50, and increases producer surplus by $20, then which of the following is incorrect? a. National welfare falls by $30. b. National welfare falls by $50. c. Deadweight loss is $30. d. The protection cost is $30. If a tariff of $10 per unit reduces the world price by $4, then a. The nation imposing the tariff must be a small nation. b. Domestic...
Question 1: While the U.S. both imports and exports computers, we import a much larger amount...
Question 1: While the U.S. both imports and exports computers, we import a much larger amount than we export. For this question, assume that the U.S. either imports completely or exports completely and that the trade balance reflects something fundamental about our resources and production costs relative to the rest of the world. Use a detailed diagram to show supply and demand in the market for computers in U.S. Label all areas in the graph in order to answer the...
Chapter 5 Import Protection Policy: Import Tariffs I. Chapter Overview 1. Types of import tariffs in...
Chapter 5 Import Protection Policy: Import Tariffs I. Chapter Overview 1. Types of import tariffs in terms of the means of collection in terms of the different tariff rates applied in terms of special purposes for collection 2. The effects of import tariffs concepts of consumers surplus and producers surplus the welfare effects of import tariffs 3. Measurement of import tariffs the "height" of import tariffs nominal versus effective tariff rates II. Chapter Summary 1. The means of collecting import...
19. The method we used to determine whether a country/society was better or worse off after...
19. The method we used to determine whether a country/society was better or worse off after a change in policy or a movement towards free trade (from autarky) was a. by calculating the net effects b. by examining the total surplus c. by considering the deadweight loss triangles d. all of the above e. none of the above (not including d) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 20. Consider the small Home country doing tariffs under PC. Which of the following statements is true? a....
Suppose you work for a US based soybean manufacturing company which supplies soybeans to other countries,...
Suppose you work for a US based soybean manufacturing company which supplies soybeans to other countries, among which are China and Nigeria. From your company’s sales records, China is responsible for 80% of your company’s global sales and Nigeria is responsible for 0.2% of your company’s sales. Your contract with the companies in both countries has just expired and the week before negotiations are set to start, it is announced that tariffs have been placed on soybeans in both countries....
QUESTION 31 A benefit of being in a customs union is,   a. a customs union tends...
QUESTION 31 A benefit of being in a customs union is,   a. a customs union tends to have more bargaining power in trade agreements than a country has by itself b. a customs union can accelerate the speed of technical advance c. both A and B d. neither A nor B 3 points    QUESTION 32 Which of the following is true regarding trade protectionism? a. intraindustry trade tends to cause more protectionist pressure than interindustry trade b. particular industries...
2. A demand curve indicate a. the maximum willingness to pay for a given quantity b.the...
2. A demand curve indicate a. the maximum willingness to pay for a given quantity b.the consumer's gain from exchange c.the market price of a good or service d. the equilibrum quantity 3. trade permitts countries to a. consume more than they capable of producing b.produce based on their comparative advantage c.specialize more fully d.all of above 4. which of the following dose not impact how elastic supply is? a. whether the supply is local or global b.the share of...
We have been using the same set of data (Data Set One) in the notes to...
We have been using the same set of data (Data Set One) in the notes to illustrate production and costs. I have provided Data Set One in both tables below. When costs were calculated in the notes, fixed costs were $200. By using the term fixed costs economists are only referring to the fact that a firm must pay this expense no matter how much output it produces or sells. An example of a fixed cost could be the rent...