Question

Some advocates of trade protection in the domestic market for steel argue that it is needed...

Some advocates of trade protection in the domestic market for steel argue that it is needed to protect domestic steelworkers' jobs. Why are economists usually unconvinced by this argument?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Answer: Economists usually unconvinced by this argument because while trade protection in the steel industry might indeed protect some domestic jobs for steelworkers but it will put many other jobs at risk. For example, a producer of auto mobile company might need steel as a critical input for production. When the steel industry is protected with an import quota, then the domestic price of steel goes up. This increases the costs for both the auto parts producer and the construction company. Which result increase in costs leading to force those firms to lay off workers. So protection of domestic steelworkers jobs will indeed come at the cost of domestic workers in other industries. And thats why economist are uncovienced by this argument.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
Opponents of free trade argue that trade must be restricted in order to save domestic jobs....
Opponents of free trade argue that trade must be restricted in order to save domestic jobs. As a free-trade, how would you counter this argument?
Explain why economists generally argue that trade creates wealth. Whether one agrees with the view held...
Explain why economists generally argue that trade creates wealth. Whether one agrees with the view held by economists is immaterial to this question: explain the economic argument.
The argument that foreign trade should be restricted to protect domestic employment and output is based...
The argument that foreign trade should be restricted to protect domestic employment and output is based on the idea that: consumers are willing to pay higher prices for domestic goods. producers will not exploit reduced foreign competition by charging higher prices. foreign companies are more costly to deal with than domestic companies. sales of imports come at the expense of domestic goods and jobs.
Some politicians, labor unions, and special interest groups argue that US trade deficits are harmful to...
Some politicians, labor unions, and special interest groups argue that US trade deficits are harmful to the economy and nations that run large trade surpluses with the US are benefiting from unfair trade practices and agreements. These parties support increasing tariffs on imports, elimination, or re-writing of trade agreements. Respond to the following in a minimum of 275 words: Discuss what credible economists say about the effects that tariffs, changing trade agreements, and/or manipulating exchange rates will have on the...
Suppose in the world market, steel is sold at $5 per ton. The domestic demand and...
Suppose in the world market, steel is sold at $5 per ton. The domestic demand and supply curves of steel in Canada are Qd =28 – 2p and Qs = -8 + 2p where Q measures the quantity in tons. i. Calculate the amount of steel that will be produced and sold domestically. How much will be imported? ii. Now suppose Canada completely bans free trade in steel. What will happen to the price and the quantity produced and sold...
1. Some argue that Sweden's generous welfare benefits, which pay people who lose their jobs as...
1. Some argue that Sweden's generous welfare benefits, which pay people who lose their jobs as much as 80 percent of previous incomes for three years, has resulted in too-high unemployment. This can be seen as an example of: a. government not correcting externalities produced by the market. b. government failure in fostering a competitive market environment. c. market failure due to unfair conditions produced by the labor market. d. globalization causing hardworking youth to emigrate. 2. A primary goal...
Take the reasons for trade protection into account and discuss what free trade does to the...
Take the reasons for trade protection into account and discuss what free trade does to the economy. When the first Japanese cars arrived on the West Coast in the 1970s, no one saw them as a threat to U.S. jobs. Although they were cheaper and more fuel-efficient than U.S.-made cars, most Americans could not be bothered; with gasoline at 30 cents a gallon, the difference in cost between a car that got 30 miles per gallon and one that got...
Monopsony. The dominant employer in Davis is UCD. Some argue that UCD uses its market power...
Monopsony. The dominant employer in Davis is UCD. Some argue that UCD uses its market power to lower the wages of some of its staff, especially those in lower-skill jobs. Show how this would work, using an inverse supply of labor of w=3+0.2L, where L is the number of hours worked per month by the labor force (in thousands), and w is the wage paid, in dollars per hour. Suppose UCD’s inverse demand for labor is w=18-0.1L. a) What are...
Why do some people argue against free trade? Please illustrate your answer with relevant examples from...
Why do some people argue against free trade? Please illustrate your answer with relevant examples from both economic and political perspectives. I need help on structuring the assignment and also ideas that will allow me to expand on as this question requires 2000 words, help will be much appreciated. Thanks Identify the requirements of the question Identify what the question wants by breaking it down into parts Use your analysis to give you focus – will help you avoid large...
1. A market economy: a. relies on the invisible hand to coordinate supply and demand. b....
1. A market economy: a. relies on the invisible hand to coordinate supply and demand. b. allocates according to need. c. requires government to set prices. d. distributes property rights. 2. A primary goal of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) is to: a. promote economic negotiations and cooperation among industrialized countries. b. work out repayment plans for developing countries with large international debts. c. negotiate trade agreements between nations. d. protect the interests of the United States abroad. 3. Some...