Question

Although the government from the state to the local level is clearly unitary, local finance is...

Although the government from the state to the local level is clearly unitary, local finance is very diverse, with many local levies and revenue streams. Should states abolish all local taxes and institute more efficient tax reforms? Why/why not?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

Under federal tax law, individuals can deduct from their total income when filing their federal taxes the income and property taxes they pay to their state and local governments, as well as any interest they earn from state-owned or local bonds. Individuals have been allowed to deduct their income tax or sales taxes in recent years Since federal tax deductions effectively spread the cost of such deductions across all taxpayers in the form of higher federal tax rates, state and local tax deductions result in federal taxpayers subsidizing taxpayers in high-tax, high-debt states in low-tax, low-debt states. As a result of these deductions, distributional impacts within states lead to low-income residents subsidizing high-income residents.

When exemptions from state and local taxes and bonds were withdrawn, federal income tax rates could be lowered by as much as 16.4%. Ending federal state and local tax and debt payments would help improve state and local government fiscal discipline and economic efficiency as taxpayers would no longer be reimbursed for some of the taxes they paid to their state or locality. Instead, the full cost of the services they rendered would be charged. In fact, municipal bond holders would no longer receive a dividend in addition to the interest earned from their municipal bonds, and government and local budgets would have to represent the full cost of any accumulated debt

Tax deductions reduce the tax base so that higher marginal tax rates are required to maintain the same level of tax revenue. Ideally, deductions should be kept to a minimum after the creation of the appropriate tax base. But many deductions and exceptions are littered with the U.S. tax code. The federal state and local tax and municipal bond interest deductions turn high-tax and high-debt states and high-income taxpayers into those special interests. Since state and local taxes reduce the after-tax income of people, it may make sense to exclude from federal taxation the income used to pay those taxes. But this was when the majority of services were provided by state and local governments and most taxes were collected. The reverse is true today, as the federal government earns more than 50% more revenue than the combined government and local governments.

As the sole collector of revenue, no tax clevel should be excluded by the federal government. By fact, the tax deduction allows states to raise taxes higher than they would otherwise, which helps governments to provide services that are left to the private sector more adequately. The tax deduction also has major adverse effects on the distribution of income from the poor to the rich and from people in low-tax states to people in high-tax countries

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
The continued constriction of local government budgets has prompted a number of cities around the country...
The continued constriction of local government budgets has prompted a number of cities around the country to look at their tax expenditures—the exemptions or other tax relief measures provided to businesses, individuals, and nonprofits. What is the justification for exempting nonprofits from paying local property taxes? From paying state and local sales taxes? What are the long-term effects to the property tax base of exempting nonprofits from the property tax? Several local governments have begun demanding payments in lieu of...
Why do local and state governments like raising the taxes on cigarettes? Multiple Choice Most long-term...
Why do local and state governments like raising the taxes on cigarettes? Multiple Choice Most long-term smokers are hooked on smoking and can’t stop this habit. Therefore, they have an inelastic demand curve and the government is simply able to take advantage of this. In these cases, the government is usually able to collect more tax revenues because the demand is inelastic. The U.S. government has traditionally set a "price floor" on tobacco prices (this is a true fact). Therefore,...
In Sufrolandia the consumption function is C = 180 + 0.8(Y − T). The government collects...
In Sufrolandia the consumption function is C = 180 + 0.8(Y − T). The government collects direct and indirect taxes according to T = 100 + 0.5 ∗ Y . Unfortunately, the tax revenue is not enough to cover the public expenditure.MadreM´ıa, a firm formed by prominent IE graduates, has been hired to design a policy that reduces the deficit. However, they recommend to increase public spending by 300 million, rather than cutting spending and raising taxes! They argue that...
[16] Over the last 25 years the dollar amount of government expenditures has been: A) increasing....
[16] Over the last 25 years the dollar amount of government expenditures has been: A) increasing. B) decreasing. C) relatively constant. D) fluctuating widely up and down. [17] Which of the following is a public good? A) A lighthouse. B) A private hospital. C) A commercial airliner. D) A corporation's charitable redevelopment of a city neighborhood. [18] A good or service that is provided for all of society, and no one is excluded from its use, is called: A) a...
Our government provides us with many valuable services such as education, public transportation, environmental protection, etc....
Our government provides us with many valuable services such as education, public transportation, environmental protection, etc. Over the years, many of its services, such as US postal service, are in direct competition with private firms that happen to be more efficient in providing services. It is evident that the government is not efficient in running a business as US postal service is consistently losing money ($5.6 Billion in 2016)*. Recently, they defaulted on future health payments. **It is especially concerning...
1.Taxes can be justified if the government uses the revenue to (i) provide public goods such...
1.Taxes can be justified if the government uses the revenue to (i) provide public goods such as national defense. (ii) clean up negative externalities such as water pollution. (iii) regulate a common resource such as fish in a public lake. (iv) provide goods with positive externalities such as medical research. A) (ii) only B) (ii) and (iii) only C) (i), (ii), and (iii) only D) (i), (ii), (iii), and (iv) 2.A person's tax liability refers to A) the percentage of...
Ford hires resources for its assembly unit in Mexico. The Ford will recruit resources to the...
Ford hires resources for its assembly unit in Mexico. The Ford will recruit resources to the point where the price of unit output equals the additional revenue that an extra unit of output produces. its total cost equals its total revenue. the marginal cost of an additional unit of resource equals the marginal revenue product of that resource. the price of unit output equals the marginal cost of the last unit of output. the average variable cost of production equals...
Governments typically finance their capital projects with general obligation debt, secured by the “full faith and...
Governments typically finance their capital projects with general obligation debt, secured by the “full faith and credit” of the government. A full faith and credit pledge implies that, unless specifically limited, the government will use its full taxing power to ensure that lenders receive timely repayment of principal and interest. When New York City faced a financial crisis in the mid-1970s, city and state leaders concluded that bankruptcy was out of the question. A combination of belt-tightening and selling secured...
Case Study When taxes induce people to change their behavior—such as inducing Jane to buy less...
Case Study When taxes induce people to change their behavior—such as inducing Jane to buy less pizza—the taxes cause deadweight losses and make the allocation of resources less efficient. As we have already seen, much government revenue comes from the individual income tax in many countries. In a case study in Chapter 8, we discussed how this tax discourages people from working as hard as they otherwise might. Another inefficiency caused by this tax is that it discourages people from...
Assignment 2-Case Study-Chapters: 7, 8, 9 & 12 (Macroeconomics) ECON201 Case Study When taxes induce people...
Assignment 2-Case Study-Chapters: 7, 8, 9 & 12 (Macroeconomics) ECON201 Case Study When taxes induce people to change their behavior—such as inducing Jane to buy less pizza—the taxes cause deadweight losses and make the allocation of resources less efficient. As we have already seen, much government revenue comes from the individual income tax in many countries. In a case study in Chapter 8, we discussed how this tax discourages people from working as hard as they otherwise might. Another inefficiency...