Question

The Pied Piper sues the Mayor of Hamelin for breach of contract. To prove the contract’s...

The Pied Piper sues the Mayor of Hamelin for breach of contract. To prove the contract’s terms, the Piper offers a photocopy of the contract into evidence, without explaining the whereabouts of the original. The Mayor objects, claiming the Best Evidence rule requires that Piper produce the original contract. How do you rule, under the FRE?

Homework Answers

Answer #1

A photocopy of the document is called as duplicate under FRE 1001(4). A duplicate is admissable as good as the original unless there is genuine concern about the authenticity of the original or it will be unfair to admit the duplicate (FRE 1003). In this case the duplicate has not been questioned about the authenticity ( as per the facts at least) and there is no reason to believe it would be unfair to admit a photocopy, the copy should be admitted notwithstanding the B.E.R.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
1- Grover initiates a breach of contract action against Todd. Grover claims the contract, which was...
1- Grover initiates a breach of contract action against Todd. Grover claims the contract, which was reduced to writing, called for Todd to deliver 200 crates of peaches by a certain date. At trial, Todd wishes to testify that the contract only called for delivery of 100 crates. Grover makes a best evidence rule objection. a.The court should sustain the objection. b.The court should overrule the objection because a contract is an agreement brought about by the meeting of two...
The differences & similarities between the federal & state court systems. 2. The structure of the...
The differences & similarities between the federal & state court systems. 2. The structure of the Washington state court system; i.e. the trial court of general jurisdiction, the intermediate appellate court, the state supreme court. 3. Remember, Washington is in the 9 th Circuit Court of Appeals. 4. Under both the Washington state and federal court system, there is one appeal as of right. Appeals to the Washington Supreme Court(in the state system), or to the U.S. Supreme Court in...
THIS TEACHING CONTRACT (''Contract'') is entered into and becomes effective as of August 11, 2019 by...
THIS TEACHING CONTRACT (''Contract'') is entered into and becomes effective as of August 11, 2019 by and between Pretend Community College (''Employer''), and Mandy Gruhlkey (''Employee''). IN CONSIDERATION of the promises and of the mutual covenants contained herein, and for other good and valuable consideration, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the parties hereto do hereby agree as follows: 1. Employment. Employer hereby engages Employee to serve as a political science and business professor and Employee hereby accepts such an...
64.    Under the UCC if Anthony transfers the right to possession and use of goods for...
64.    Under the UCC if Anthony transfers the right to possession and use of goods for a term in return for consideration to Betty this would be a a. transfer b. lease c. gift d. sale e. nothing, this would not be covered by the UCC 65.    A ________ is a corporation in which the shares are held by one shareholder or a small group of shareholders and the stock is not actively traded. a. close corporation b. small corporation...
64.    Under the UCC if Anthony transfers the right to possession and use of goods for...
64.    Under the UCC if Anthony transfers the right to possession and use of goods for a term in return for consideration to Betty this would be a a. transfer b. lease c. gift d. sale e. nothing, this would not be covered by the UCC 65.    A ________ is a corporation in which the shares are held by one shareholder or a small group of shareholders and the stock is not actively traded. a. close corporation b. small corporation...
of Contract can you please go into detail with for 400 words or more thank you...
of Contract can you please go into detail with for 400 words or more thank you Johnny, a neighbor who is not a merchant under the Uniform Commercial Code, offers to buy a car from Mark for $30,000. Mark asks Johnny for some time to think about it. Johnny says sure. He writes on a piece of paper that he will keep the offer open for two weeks. A week later Johnny sees another car he would rather buy. He...
Rules of Evidence Under the rules of evidence, a judge may exclude relevant evidence for a...
Rules of Evidence Under the rules of evidence, a judge may exclude relevant evidence for a variety of reasons. Which of the following is a situation where a judge can refuse to admit relevant evidence? The evidence is unduly prejudicial The evidence is hypothetical The evidence might be offensive The evidence is narrative ________________ is defined as anything perceptible by the fives senses and any proof legally presented at trial to prove a contested issue and induce a belief in...
QUESTION 1 A contract induced by improper threats or undue influence is void. True False 1...
QUESTION 1 A contract induced by improper threats or undue influence is void. True False 1 points    QUESTION 2 A contract made by a person under guardianship is voidable. True False 1 points    QUESTION 3 A contract with a minor remains in force unless the minor decides that he or she does not wish to be bound by it. True False 1 points    QUESTION 4 A person who was intoxicated at the time he made a contract...
1. Evidence that relates to, or bears directly upon, the point or fact in issue, and...
1. Evidence that relates to, or bears directly upon, the point or fact in issue, and proves or has a tendency to prove the proposition alleged, is relevant evidence. T OR F? 2. Evidence is legally material and admissible if it relates to a fact in issue and has only a slight bearing on the matter in issue. T OR F? 3. Photographic evidence of a gruesome crime scene may be admitted if it is probative of a fact in...
Select one of the three incidents among patient identification error, a medication error, and a HIPAA/privacy...
Select one of the three incidents among patient identification error, a medication error, and a HIPAA/privacy violation Consider the following analysis questions once you have selected the incident on which you will focus: What information do you possess about the issue? (Note: You may not be able to answer all of these questions; just include the information you know.) Consider: Who was involved? During what process (clinical, communication, or operational) did the issue occur? When did the issue occur? During...