Question

Scott E. Miller, CPA, CVA has given an example of an expert witness in his article...

Scott E. Miller, CPA, CVA has given an example of an expert witness in his article entitled “You Got the Litigation Engagement, So Now What,” in The Value Examiner. Read his example and then prepare a list of mistakes that the expert made in his expert witnessing engagement.

Let’s assume there is a CPA, Calvin P. Anderson. Calvin has been a practicing CPA for 15 years. He has a successful CPA firm providing a full range of traditional accounting and tax services but does no litigation support or business appraisal services. Neither Calvin nor his staff have any experience in litigation support or business valuation.

Calvin learns from another CPA that litigation support and business valuation can provide profitable growth areas for CPA firms. He remembers hearing and reading about these practice areas being growth areas for CPA firms and decides that he is interested and wants to consider providing this type of work. His friend informs him of an upcoming three-day seminar on litigation support that he should attend. Calvin takes the class and gets fired up about the prospects of entering this new and exciting practice area.

When he gets back to his office, he immediately calls all his attorney prospects and lets them know he can provide these services. He develops marketing literature that he sends to his attorney contacts and many other attorneys in his local area.

It’s now mid-July and he gets a call from an attorney with a large firm in his hometown. Calvin is excited. Working for such a large firm like this one could really help his litigation practice grow. The attorney, Justin C. Esquire, with Peterson, Jones, Haskins and Dingle, LLP asks him about his current practice, education, experience, and whether he has any experience with economic analysis. Calvin says, “Of course, I have been doing financial analysis for over 15 years as a part of assisting my clients and besides, you have to analyze financial statements when you do financial statement work.” When Esquire asks if he has any experience testifying before, Calvin says yes, knowing that the only time he did was when a client was getting divorced and they asked him to comment on the income reported on his client’s tax returns. He thinks, “It was so easy, this can’t be much different.” Esquire asks his fees and Calvin tells him $150 per hour. Calvin had heard that you could get premium rates for litigation work, so he quoted 20 percent above his normal rate of $125 per hour. Esquire tells Calvin he is willing to pay $135 per hour. Calvin, thinking he is getting a $10 per hour premium, jumps at the chance. Esquire realizes $135 per hour is cheap and that Calvin is not asking for a retainer. Esquire thinks he is getting a great deal for his client.

Mr. Esquire says, “Okay. Let me talk to my client, and I will call you in a couple of weeks.” Calvin is excited but nervous. He can’t wait to start, but realizes this is new territory for him. Two weeks go by, and he doesn’t hear from Esquire. Three weeks later, he gets the call from Esquire. His client has approved the cost of hiring Calvin. Esquire says he will prepare the engagement letter and mail it to Calvin for signature.

Calvin waits for the engagement letter. It is now late August and the engagement letter hasn’t come. He sends Esquire an email about the status of the engagement letter, and Esquire responds that he is busy now but will get to it. In late September, the engagement letter comes; Calvin signs it and immediately returns it to Mr. Esquire without carefully reviewing it first.

Esquire calls him in the first week of October and discusses the engagement. It is a wrongful termination action and Esquire represents the employer. He explains to Calvin that he needs to make sure the damages figure is low, because he thinks his client could lose. Calvin tells Esquire that he will do the best that he can but can’t guarantee the result will be what his client wants. Esquire ignores the comment and says he will be sending over a package of information for Calvin.

In the third week of October, the package arrives. The package contains a copy of the plaintiff’s (Emily Broke) last three paychecks showing she earned a salary of $4,000 per month, a copy of her last two years’ tax returns, a typed list of her benefits, and a brief letter stating that Emily Broke was a senior training manager at a manufacturing company. She started in May 1991 and was terminated on December 23, 2001, after complaining about her manager’s sexual advances.

Calvin reviews the information and begins to calculate her potential damages. The benefits listed are medical and dental insurance, three weeks of vacation, and two weeks of sick pay per year. He includes in his analysis her lost wages, lost medical and dental benefits, lost vacation, and lost sick pay. There is no information about the actual employer cost of her medical and dental insurance. Calvin thinks about it and decides that since it is only an estimate, he could use a “reasonable” proxy for the cost, so he looks at his own medical and dental insurance bill and uses his cost of $450 per month to project her lost benefits.

Calvin calls a friend of his who is an account executive at a temporary placement firm to find out how long it normally takes someone to find a job like Ms. Broke’s. His friend tells him that most people find a job in three to six months. Thinking he is being generous, Calvin calculates six months of wages and medical and dental benefits and the accrued vacation and sick pay she would have received had she remained with the company.

Calvin adds it all up and emails the amount to Mr. Esquire in the first week of November. His analysis is as follows:

Lost wages (6 x $4,000)

$24,000

Lost benefits (6 x $450)

2,700

Lost vacation (3/4 x $4,000)

3,000

Lost sick pay (2/4 x $4,000)

    2,000

Total lost wages & benefits

$31,700

List the mistakes that Calvin made. The response can be in essay form, numbered, or bulleted.

Homework Answers

Answer #1

The following are the mistakes that Calvin made in the above mentioned question:

  1. Taking the class and geting fired up about the prospects of entering this new and exciting practice area
  2. Developing marketing literature and sending to his attorney contacts and many other attorneys in his local area.
  3. Including in his analysis; Emily's lost wages, lost medical and dental benefits, lost vacation, and lost sick pay.

There are many other mistakes that Calvin did but the above three mistakes are major mistakes according to me.

Know the answer?
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for?
Ask your own homework help question
Similar Questions
The F.B.I. just left your office. An anonymous woman had provided the local office with an...
The F.B.I. just left your office. An anonymous woman had provided the local office with an envelope of photographs showing your client involved in sexual conduct. Several of the pictures showed him with what appeared to be teenagers. There was also a taped phone conversation between your client and a man - a conversation that explicitly described their “date” a few weeks earlier. The F.B.I. wanted to know what you knew about any of this and cautioned you NOT to...
Shamus’s family come to talk to you about their his care. They want to speak to...
Shamus’s family come to talk to you about their his care. They want to speak to you because they trust you as someone who has worked very closely with Shamus as a palliative care worker for the last two months. They are very distressed about a report they have received from the doctor, who has told them that Shamus has only days to live. His family ask you to refer them to a different doctor – there must be something...
Powerpoint slides for COPD with the given case study by using CRC. Ms Aaliyah Abimbola Background...
Powerpoint slides for COPD with the given case study by using CRC. Ms Aaliyah Abimbola Background information for the assignment. You are the RN on a morning shift on the respiratory ward of a large inner-city hospital. At 10:30 AM you receive a patient from the Emergency Department. This is the hand-over you receive. I My name is Catriona and I am the A&E RN who has been caring for Ms Aaliyah Abimbola. Thank you so much for taking this...
Chapter 1: Bob becomes a real estate investor It is November 2007 and the economy of...
Chapter 1: Bob becomes a real estate investor It is November 2007 and the economy of Bob is a recent art school graduate working as an actor on a new Tyler Perry movie. Bob got a wonderful 6 month contract with a 3 month advance on pay. After Bob’s second day of work he was getting gas and a new Ferrari pulled up in the next stall. Bob was amazed and started a conversation. It turns out the owner of...
Powerpoint slides for COPD with the given case study by using CRC. Ms Aaliyah Abimbola Background...
Powerpoint slides for COPD with the given case study by using CRC. Ms Aaliyah Abimbola Background information for the assignment. You are the RN on a morning shift on the respiratory ward of a large inner-city hospital. At 10:30 AM you receive a patient from the Emergency Department. This is the hand-over you receive. I My name is Catriona and I am the A&E RN who has been caring for Ms Aaliyah Abimbola. Thank you so much for taking this...
Powerpoint slides for COPD with the given case study by using CRC. Ms Aaliyah Abimbola Background...
Powerpoint slides for COPD with the given case study by using CRC. Ms Aaliyah Abimbola Background information for the assignment. You are the RN on a morning shift on the respiratory ward of a large inner-city hospital. At 10:30 AM you receive a patient from the Emergency Department. This is the hand-over you receive. I My name is Catriona and I am the A&E RN who has been caring for Ms Aaliyah Abimbola. Thank you so much for taking this...
Case Study: Henderson Printing is a small- to medium-sized manufacturer of account books, ledgers, and various...
Case Study: Henderson Printing is a small- to medium-sized manufacturer of account books, ledgers, and various types of record books used in business. Located in Halifax, the company has annual sales of about $12 million, mostly in the Atlantic provinces. The owner, George Henderson, is a firm believer in making a high-quality product that will stand up to many years of use. He uses only high-grade paper, cover stock, and binding materials. Of course, this has led to high production...
Facts from Client Interview Tumutch and Lotta Bolloni have been married for four years. They both...
Facts from Client Interview Tumutch and Lotta Bolloni have been married for four years. They both work very hard at their jobs – Lotta being an accountant and Tumutch working as a construction manager. They decide to splurge and look into booking an all-inclusive vacation to the enchanting Fantasy Island, in Fiji for February 2020. The Bollonis do some research into different travel packages and get quotes from various agencies. They narrow their choices down to three possibilities: Travelcations &...
QUESTION 1 ? What is the relationship between family dysfunction and schizophrenia? a. ?Research has substantiated...
QUESTION 1 ? What is the relationship between family dysfunction and schizophrenia? a. ?Research has substantiated a link between family dysfunction and schizophrenia but can't say which causes the other. b. ?Family dysfunction is a major causative factor for schizophrenia. c. ?Research has failed to substantiate a direct causal link between family dysfunction and schizophrenia. d. ?Family dysfunction plays a minor role in developing schizophrenia. 1.00000 points    QUESTION 2 ? Chuck has no life plan; he simply lives from...
INTRO NewForm IT is a seven-year-old IT consulting company founded in 2012 that provides services to...
INTRO NewForm IT is a seven-year-old IT consulting company founded in 2012 that provides services to small businesses in their local and regional area. NewForm employs 83 people, 61 of whom are IT professionals/ consultants. NewForm is struggling financially; it has not met its revenue projections in the last five quarters. NewForm has suffered excessive leadership turnover in the past three years. The original founders sold NewForm in 2015; one of them, James Stanton, remained on as CHRO but sold...
ADVERTISEMENT
Need Online Homework Help?

Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 1 hours.

Ask a Question
ADVERTISEMENT