Question

AAA Trucking Company files a suit in a state court against Miller’s Service Company, and wins. MSC appeals the court’s decision, asserting that the evidence presented at trail to support AAA’s claim was so scanty that no reasonable jury could have found for the plaintiff. Therefore, argues MSC, the appellate court should reverse the trail court’s decision. Is the appellate court likely to reverse the trail court’s findings with respect to the facts? If not, why not? What are the appellate court’s options after reviewing a case?

Answer 1

Answer

Yes, Apple's court can reverse the court's findings in relation to the facts, but only then the MSC claims that "so far the claims are too few that there could not be a suitable jury for the plaintiff". It is true that the Apple Court can reverse a lawsuit if the decision is contrary to the evidence presented in the trial or is contrary to the court's decision or there is insufficient or no evidence to support the find.

After removing the case again, the court of applet has to consider the case if the facts were presented quite by both the parties and find out whether the evidence presented in the trial court was sufficient and then decsison whether the trial court Reverse or adjourn the verdict.